The mix of rock makes this difficult. There are two images that will allow me to tell the species. First, if the animal threatens at you or at least looks at you head on, what color is the meral spot (depressiion on the inside of the striking appendage. If it is orange or yellow, you probably have an Indo-Pacific animal in the Gonodactyllaceus group. If it is white, it is probably a Neogonodactylus from the Caribbean. Second, I need to see the teeth on the tail. That will allow me to identify it with some certainty.
Roy