Need CUC advice...

soulbereaver

New member
Ok, thought peppermints were ok, but have been hearing bad things about them. Thought small cowrie snail was ok, but now hearing bad things about them...hermits are hit or miss... cucumbers will kill an entire tank supposedly if they die...

So what clean-up-crew is 100% reef safe with SPS, and also efficient enough to keep the tank clean of algae and pests like aiptasia??


Thanks.
 
Aiptasia:
-I think peppermints are the only solution to these.
Bad things have been said about these, it really is hit or miss. They will do the job, but many people complain (including me) that they attack newly added, or even corals that have been in the tank. But, I don't think peppermints will attack SPS, they have only attacked (on my record) LPS, Sessile Inverts, Polyps, and SOME other soft corals.
-There are also some nudibranchs that will eat them but these are rare and hard to come across.

Algae:
-Emerald Crabs are good for getting algae.
-Hermit Crabs, Its not hit or miss, it depends on what kind you buy. The small ones (usually not over 1") that come in color morphs from blue to red to brown are the reef safe guys and won't hurt anything. And the blue knuckled ones and SOME other hermits are completely reef safe and are an essential component to a reef.
-Turbo Snails, Ceriths, Abalones, etc. are excellent for taking care of filmy algae on glass.
-Sea Hares are the best for large algae problems, but must be fed when no more food is present or they will quickly starve. And pumps/anything they can be sucked into should be covered.

Other:
-Nassarius snails are terrific, and a great part of your clean-up crew. They will eat dead/decaying things and sometimes leftover food
-Serpent Stars-same as above^
-Cleaner shrimp (skunk cleaner, fire etc) are probably the best thing you can have as your cleanup crew. They will eat ANYTHING, even fish poop. And they are beautiful additions to your tank.

Hope this helps ;)
 
Basically crabs are all opturnistic feeders so its 50:50 personally I don't keep crabs due to this factor.

Cuke's are a different story. If your tank is the 75 gallon. An atlantic or tiger tail would be 100% reef safe. I currently keep an atlantic in as 90 gallon with no bad issues.

Fan worms or feather duster are 100% safe they remove fine food particles.

For snails nassarius vibex are probably the best out of all the snails (but you have to watch out when adding them to the tank because occasionally they will mislabeled and they will send you onyx nassarius which are only fish safe not reef safe). Turbo, astrea and cerith are 100% safe.
Their are only two types of sea urchin that I believe are reef safe and they are long spined and blue tuxedo.

For starfish they all have the potential to capture and eat a fish so none of them are truly reef safe except for mini brittle stars or micro stars these you can't buy for they are just to small to collect but you are likely to get a bunch if you purchase live rock.

Bristle worms are a 100% reef safe as long as you don't have fire worms which are coral eaters.
For shrimp only cleaner shrimp are reef safe 100%.

Sea hares are not reef safe at all for they need more of a quiet macro algae tank where they can constantly eat and they also require low current and plenty of food.

If you are looking for a good guide on buying invertebrates try
Marine Invertebrates by Ronald L. Shimek, Ph.D.
 
Sorry I missed the aiptasia question peppermint shrimp have been known to eat aiptasia but they are also likely to eat most polyps. Peppermint shrimp are about a 25% chance they will eat the aiptasia so in my opinion they are not worth it. With the nudibranch that tennyson is talking about is also a 25% chance they will eat it.
The best way to get rid of aiptasia is with Joe's juice.
 
Back
Top