That would be Nature's Best, out in Vestal on 26S, Owner Rick is a great guy, store is a bit of a whole, but the owner is a good guy and has been making a lot of changes / upgrades to the place.I can recommend a place that I visit once a year. Kind of a hole in the wall, BUT they have crazy sales. Every 31st, he puts livestock at 1/2 price, and equipment at 20%, and dry goods 10% (I may have mixed up the sales on equipment and goods). I've never had a problem with bad fish from there either.
I don't know the name off hand, I will get back to you on that.
...If you didn't know, they sell salt water fish at Livingstons animal kingdom next to kmart on state st....