ORA Mandarin Dragonets!!!!!

Wild Caught Mandarins sell for $18 locally. I'd pay up to 2x that for a captive bred one that is eating prepared foods.

Any more than that and they will have trouble selling them I think.
 
It doesn't have anything to do with breeding. A captive-bred fish that's been in a controlled environment hasn't been exposed to the same potential parasites and diseases that a wild-caught fish has. Since the slime coat that helps fend off ich is part of the mandarins' physiology, I doubt it would--or could--be bred out of them.

I don't know much about genetics, but did notice the color of the ora mandarins are not similiar to the typical wild caught ones (I personally think the wild caught colors look better). I think if they are able to breed them into a different color and eating habits, I won't be surprised if other characteristics can change. I would never say never.
 
Wild Caught Mandarins sell for $18 locally. I'd pay up to 2x that for a captive bred one that is eating prepared foods.

Any more than that and they will have trouble selling them I think.

Considering what most reefkeepers spend on their tanks and equipment, I think an extra $20 or even $30 on a CB fish over a WC isn't really *that* big of a deal. The number of fish you can add to your tank is finite...you're talking about a one-time investment, unless you're constantly switching your fish out (which, I admit, I've done before--in which case it can add up pretty quickly). Nobody's going to go broke buying CB instead of WC. Skip a couple of meals out, or a few trips to Starbucks, and you've made up the difference. :)
 
I don't know much about genetics, but did notice the color of the ora mandarins are not similiar to the typical wild caught ones (I personally think the wild caught colors look better). I think if they are able to breed them into a different color and eating habits, I won't be surprised if other characteristics can change. I would never say never.

Most likely the eating habits are the result of training and conditioning, same as with WC mandarins whose owners have trained them to accept pellets and frozen foods. The problem is that for every WC mandarin that learns to eat "dead" foods (and the ones that do tend to be the exception rather than the rule), countless others perish--not only in the process of being collected and shipped, but also when they land in the tanks of hobbyists who aren't prepared to care for them (or even stores--I wish I had a dollar for every sorry-looking, emaciated, doomed dragonet I've seen for sale in aquarium shops). That's where the losses mount up, and that's why CB fish are so important.

As far as the slime coat vs. colors...I doubt it. I'm not a geneticist, so I can't predict for sure, but I would think that differing patterns and colors are a lot less "fixed" than a survival characteristic like a slime coat that is part of the fish's inherent make-up. But I could be wrong. Any marine biologists here?
 
I'm in, can't wait. I'd gladly pay $50-60 for one of these beauties. Now I need to figure out which LFS around me deals ORA stuff.
 
Imagine the possibilities this opens up! One could responsibly put a CB mandarin that is eating pellets in an otherwise appropriately sized nano tank, for instance. Awesome news.
 
Imagine the possibilities this opens up! One could responsibly put a CB mandarin that is eating pellets in an otherwise appropriately sized nano tank, for instance. Awesome news.

The problem with this is that typically, even when they are fed prepared foods several times a day, mandarins will still starve if kept without a sustainable pod population. You can find wild mandarins that eat pellets, and yet they are not able to live off of pellets alone. I don't see how the ORA mandarins will be any different.
 
I'd always be willing to pay more for a CB fish. Usually, superior to WC in every respect. Look at CB Clowns compared to WC clown survival. Much better.
Good work ORA, Keep it up!

Matthew
 
The problem with this is that typically, even when they are fed prepared foods several times a day, mandarins will still starve if kept without a sustainable pod population. You can find wild mandarins that eat pellets, and yet they are not able to live off of pellets alone. I don't see how the ORA mandarins will be any different.

they do live off pelets alone. as long as its nutritionally complete youre golden.


if it still eats and dies then it had internal parasites or another problem.
 
they do live off pelets alone. as long as its nutritionally complete youre golden.


if it still eats and dies then it had internal parasites or another problem.



+1

I know a guy who keeps a pair in a 20ish gallon seagrass tank. Very little live rock in the tank, maybe 10lbs?

No way they are getting much of any copepod food from that tank. They do eat the smallest size NLA Pellets and Nutramar OVA. Those 2 items make up 95% of their diet.
 
+1

I know a guy who keeps a pair in a 20ish gallon seagrass tank. Very little live rock in the tank, maybe 10lbs?

No way they are getting much of any copepod food from that tank. They do eat the smallest size NLA Pellets and Nutramar OVA. Those 2 items make up 95% of their diet.

i think its because these fish arent obligate on certain types of food. theyre just carnivores and if you fill that need then they are fine. now coralivores and such are a different story
 
they do live off pelets alone. as long as its nutritionally complete youre golden.


if it still eats and dies then it had internal parasites or another problem.

+2

A good read is about how Matt Wittenrich bred manadarins. He initially used live myside shrimp, but later moved on to prepared foods for both the parents and young.
 
Back
Top