perfect storm

dendrite

New member
I did a 25 % water change on a 2 1/2 year old 180 gallon reef, thinking it would be nice to clean out some accumulated chlorides and what ever else might be building. I used RSCP mixed to 1.026. Since I had some time on my hands from the long weekend I also changed the calcium reactor media, adding some KZ magnesium chips to the mixed, I also increased the radions during the mid day to 95% and 12,000 K from 90% and 14,000 K. Needless to say within 24 hours I lost ten head Hammer, an eight inch green slimer that I have had for years, an M. undata also long time and a large 9 inch ponapes birdnest. Checking my parameters showed a jump in dKh from my usual 7.5 to 10.5 . The phosphates were 0, and the nitrates were .25 ppm. SG was 1.026. The Mg was 1600. I checked the newly mixed salt from the holding tank which was dKh of 12. I think the lesson to be learned is:
a] one change at a time
b] perhaps when adding a second source of Mg one should perhaps cut back on the dosing
c] feed more despite already feeding a heavy fish population, and perhaps a healthy macroalgae refugium along with vodka dosing is overkill.
d] pretty much done with the expensive premium salts which raise carbonate and calcium well beyond my tank levels. My pay so much more for maybe a dollars worth of extra calcium and baking soda?

If anyone has any additional insights I would be happy to hear them
 
I've done things like that and killed many coral. If I make any changes to my tank it's one thing at a time and watch for at least a week to see if my tank responds well.

I'm terrified to do water changes myself because ESV Salt runs about 9dkh and my tank likes the 7-8 dkh range. Wish there was a salt that was 7.5 dkh, 450 CA, and 1400 MG, but it's probably too much to ask for.

I run a skimmer, filter sock, and Chaetomorpha as my main filtration. No gfo, carbon, vodka dosing, or biopellets. Nothing fancy, modern, or state of the art. Keep it simple works for my koi pond and my cichlid tank so why not saltwater. I've learned to let my tank find it's balance and run it the way it wants to run. My LPS are doing great.
 
As time goes by I definitely think less is more. I read about all the new equipment and procedures and think that it should do the trick, but all it does is introduce another variable into an already complicated system, and something else to take apart, clean , reassemble usually at 6 AM before work. Any thoughts on Coralife or Kent salt. Both unbelievably cheap on Foster/Smith
 
Ouch! I'm sorry to hear about your losses. I agree that making changes slowly generally is a lot safer.
 
the long weekends can be dangerous to my tanks. Too much time to play. I think the combination of rapidly elevating dKh, low nutrients, and increased light tipped the balance. It's funny but those long held coral colonies were the last I would have expected to go, most of the newer sps frags survived well....... at least so far. Turned down the lights, raised the pH trip point on the calcium reactor and keeping my fingers crossed. No point in a water change since the new water would have an even higher carbonate level
 
I think that's a great idea, that, and switching salts. Do you use muriatic acid to bring down the dKh if too high?
 
Thanks. Will probably finish up the three buckets of RSCP that I have and bring down the buffer to a more compatible level with muriatic acid, and then switch out salt with multiple smaller water changes over several weeks.
 
the muriatic acid was pretty impressive. 10 cc brought the dKH in 40 gallons down from 11 to 8.5. Perfect for my water changes
 
Back
Top