MiddletonMark
Premium Member
Bomber said:Don't you guys think a certain number of tank turn overs per hour is like in lighting saying watts per gallon?
Oh come on! Aren't we allowed to have some silly rule to mis-apply?
First the `dump SD in and no problems' doesn't work that way, then watts per gallon is not accurate, now _x times flow isn't just some formula ... what do you want, us to customize things for what we stock?
Next you'll be saying that I have to feed differently depending on what I stock, or that skimmer-tank-size recommendations aren't always accurate.
Sheesh, it's like we have to think for ourselves or something

j/k ... I'm in agreement. I almost got caught in that deep-end myself with plans to make some giant closed loop to increase flow [though I still don't like my powerheads hiding behind my aquascape] .... thankfully the Salifert testing gods reminded me this last weekend that with zero Nitrates and visibly growing and nicely colored SPS in my tank that maybe I have enough flow.
Even though I'm a reluctant barebottom guy with about 1/2" or a less of mixed cc/sandy substrate [had to replace a little, as in last 5 months of siphoning with water changes had me down to glass again for over 60% of tank]. Thankfully I placed most of my flow going thru the rocks, behind the rocks, and in the inaccessible places so that the only place detritus collects is where it's easy to access [front glass] which is where all my substrate ends up [thus removed regularly in siphoning - but still there for the visual effect I'm still hooked on].
Just waiting to get lazy [and married] this summer and probably will just end up with not replacing any when it's gone next time ...
Just glad as heck that to my logic DSB sketched me out, even though I had it recommended all the time. The BB thread kept me from going there anyway ... and now healthy tank and no nitrates have shown me that flow + wet skimming + balanced import/export and maintenance = no sink nor the appearance of the Nitrate boogeyman I was taught to fear.
Anyway - enough ranting ... just happy for the good advice from all you `wise guys'
