Planned additions—review needed

[SeaCucumberFan]

I want someone to review my planned additions to my 25 gallon tank that might as well be a 30 gallon.
-More mushroom corals
-SPS corals
-A filter feeding sea cucumber
-Sea hare
-Lettuce sea slug
-Hermits
-Brittle stars
-Feather dusters
-Feather star
-Skunk cleaner shrimp
-Some kind of macroalgae
-Small frogfish (wartskin)

(No comments on the fish please, I know)
Here are the animals I don't want to get eaten:
-Unidentified sea cucumber
-Valentini puffer
-Donut coral
-Mushroom corals
-Green BTA
-Bee sponge
-Coral banded shrimp
-Pajama Cardinal

Here are the animals I fear will bother/eat the planned aditions.
-Coral banded shrimp
-Blue damsel
-Valentini puffer
-Camel shrimp

 

[SeaCucumberFan]

Bump

 

[Reel North]

Your tank is nowhere large enough for sea slugs etc. It's a small tank, and I fear that you are headed for a disaster with that stock list

 

[SeaCucumberFan]

Your tank is nowhere large enough for sea slugs etc. It's a small tank, and I fear that you are headed for a disaster with that stock list

-More mushroom corals
-SPS corals
-A filter feeding sea cucumber
-Sea hare No
-Lettuce sea slug No
-Hermits
-Brittle stars
-Feather dusters
-Feather star No
-Skunk cleaner shrimp
-Some kind of macroalgae
-Small frogfish (wartskin)

That good?

 

[Bent]

I want someone to review my planned additions to my 25 gallon tank that might as well be a 30 gallon.
-More mushroom corals fine
-SPS corals fine
-A filter feeding sea cucumber fine
-Sea hare will get sucked into powerhead, needs lots of algae and seaweed feedings. Can be picky eaters.
-Lettuce sea slugwill get sucked into powerhead
-Hermits fine
-Brittle stars fine, be wary of specific species, some are fish eaters.
-Feather dusters fine
-Feather star fine, same recs as the brittle
-Skunk cleaner shrimp will be eaten by frog fish
-Some kind of macro-algae dragonsbreath?
-Small frogfish (wartskin) will not do well with high flow that the sps will need. He will get pushed around hard. Frogs don't do well with tank mates either. They tend to be shy and get out competed for food. They really need their own tank that's set up just for the individual species to meet its specific needs. A mixed community reef is the opposite of ideal for a frog

(No comments on the fish please, I know)
Here are the animals I don't want to get eaten:
-Unidentified sea cucumber
-Valentini puffer
-Donut coral
-Mushroom corals
-Green BTA
-Bee sponge
-Coral banded shrimp Will be eaten by frog
-Pajama Cardinal Will be eaten by frog

Here are the animals I fear will bother/eat the planned aditions.
-Coral banded shrimp will become a fish eater if the frog doesn't get it first.
-Blue damsel will be Satan in a 30g. Get rid of it. Eventually the frog will take care of it anyway.
-Valentini puffer will eat the inverts
-Camel shrimp Will be eaten by frog

30g will be fine for the slugs IMO

 

[johnike]

^^^^ Ben speaketh wisely.

 

[SeaCucumberFan]

Ok heres what I have now:
-All those corals
-Brittle stars
-Small feather star
-Filter feeding cuke
-Feather dusters
-Macroalgae

Good?

 

[Bent]

Ok heres what I have now:
-All those corals
-Brittle stars
-Small feather star
-Filter feeding cuke
-Feather dusters
-Macroalgae

Good?

Do you already have fish in it? You could still set it up to keep a warty if you don't already have this 90% finished.

 

[SeaCucumberFan]

No, the tank is finished, though I might turn it into a frogfish tank in the distant future. It also needs substractions (Dang you LFS for adding sailfin and vlamingii)