quarts snad? pros and cons

Devaji108

New member
Let talk about quarts silica sand "¦I found some really nice white sand that I WOULD LIKE TO USE FOR MY UPAND COMING REEF . it is manmade and pure quarts the most common rock I believe"¦
I know most reef sand is calcium carbonate"¦anyway lets talk about it.
the possible effect of silica.
 
No pH buffering, high silicate levels, just not for reef use.

P.S. it's Quartz.

Exactly. Silicate may fuel unwanted algae growth as well, no ph buffering for sure. If your looking for a high grade very white sand try caribsea fiji pink. Even though a lot of sands look brown/tan they will be white under your lighting, guaranteed. Stay away from anything not aragonite based.
 
You get virtually no pH buffering from calcium carbonate sand either. Your pH would have to be pretty far out of whack for the sand to start dissolving and releasing carbonate ions at any appreciable rate. You can be thankful that that doesn't happen though since you would have to constantly replace your sandbed as it disappeared and your corals, snails, and LR would be constantly shrinking as well.

New quartz sand can release silicates for a while, and those can fuel diatom growth, but having high silicates won't fuel diatoms unless you also have high nitrate and phosphate to feed the algae. Some people actually dose silicates to promote sponge growth. Also, the initial release of silicates is due to contaminants in the sand, and after they are used up, the sand itself is chemically inert. It will not continue to release silicates forever.

The biggest concern is that if you get it caught between your magnet and the glass, you can scratch the glass, whereas aragonite is too soft to do that. The second biggest concern is that it has a translucent look to it in the tank that some people just don't like. If that doesn't bother you and you are careful not to scratch the glass, there is no real reason not to use quartz sand in a reef tank. It's not going to give you water quality problems or cut your sand sifters. Many people use it in reef tanks quite successfully.
 
P.S. it's Quartz....haha yes it is it was late and I had a few cocktails. :)

humm i guess it is just one of those things In this hobby that we will debate and debate some more.
it's just tempting B/c it's so cheap. would rather spend the $100 + on corals, fish lights etc.
but on the other hand if I do get huge agile blooms I will always wounder about the sand.
so I guess in the end it just not worth it.

anyone with feedback that is using it??
 
Back
Top