I'd go for the fluorescent compact, especially if you're just going to stick with softies for now. You can put the money into getting those inverts! The only difference I see, is that one is JBJ, the other's generic. LED one also has a protein skimmer, but you can get one cheaper off the net that will most likely fit the tank. Additionally, if you can get it off of DFS, then go ahead and buy some Base Rock (10 lbs), and 10 lbs of dead sand, since your LFS is charging an arm and a leg for so much live rock and sand.