Between the Reeflo & the Volcano? There are few
Reeflo Advantages:
1. Cheaper
2. Machine Welded / cleaner
3. High Bubble Density
Reeflo Disadvantages:
1. Cheaper
2. NOT modular. It is what it is. can't get inside to clean. Metric plumbing.
Volcano Advantages:
1. Hand made in the US - Every piece is "custom" made for your application
2. Scott will build it as you need it. Need the intake on the left? OK.
3. Fully modular. I was able to take the skimmer apart in 5 minutes, including the diffuser chamber & bottom box.
4. Bottom, Lid & flanges were PVC, not acrylic. Less prone to break on impact.
5. OPTIONS! Wetneck? OK. Spraydown? OK. Carbon Lid? OK. Auto Shutoff? OK. Custom Height? OK.
6. Scott directly - when you can get a hold of him, you have 1 person to talk to.
Volcano Disadvantages:
1. Price.
2. (#6) - Scott. He is a 1 man shop. He is great to work with. NEVER LET ME DOWN in the end. But sometimes it took a few tries to get a hold of him, and he is backlogged. He said that will change soon, as he is getting help in the shop.
3. Not machine welded. While Scotts workmanship is great, it does not match the reeflo's picture perfect machine welds 100%.
This NEVER once was an issue to me.
All of his welds were solid & true. His cuts are clean, as they are CNC'ed - but you can tell on a few welds that they are done by hand. This would NOT deter, or keep me in the slightest to buy from scott again. This was only on the inside of the skimmer, around the cone. Was not visible from outside, and I did not see this until i cleaned the skimmer for the new owner. This is a Hand Built, Custom product for you.
I have to say the decision was NOT easy by any means. The skimmer was very very well built, and had the options I was longing for when I had the regular reeflo 250. I just had the urge to play with the reeflo 250 PRO and test it out. What can I say .. I get around.