Tap water is your culprit. My local tap water has an alk of 25 dkh. Takes almost two full syringes to get the color change. I don't use it for my reef or even my freshwater tank. If you're not keeping sps it's probably fine, but why not at least get close to natural seawater levels. Your municipal water quality report should be available online. The last time my local water report was released was in 2011, but the alk, calcium magnesium, and phosphate tests still line up with what the report says. That's the best thing about rodi water. Not its cleanliness, but instead, the ability to control your major parameters. Raising a parameter is easy enough, but if you're in salinity range, and one parameter is too high, there's not much you can do to fix it