SkyReef
New member
Short Question:
Is it safe to have the bottom rim of a tank lie a mere 1/4" inch from the edge of a square hole (5"x5") that was cut in the plywood top of a stand? Even if the square hole exposes the "end" stud beneath the hole, somewhat?
Long Explanation and Pictures:
A. The Tank and Stand
Photo: Note that the tank sits atop the left portion of the stand, with a right-side cabinet compartment beneath
the portion of the stand where there is no tank. This may help stabilize the sheathing over the stand, to compensate
for the plywood square hole that extends across the "airspace" of the "end" stud.
___________________________
B. The Square Hole in the Top of the Stand
Photo: Note the tan wood "line" in the picture above, to the right of the top bulkhead:
that is the exposed "end" stud below the plywood. This shows that the bottom rim of
the tank is resting on the plywood with a 1/4" to spare, but beyond that to the left, the
plywood is "vacated" off the stud below by 1 inch, leaving only 1/2 inch of the stud covered
by the plywood. This only occurs for 5 of 24 inches of the end run, i.e., the length of
the square hole. Above the square hole--or to the north of it--the plywood closes back up again,
over the entire area of the plywood top.
___________________________
A close up of the square hole:
Photo: Here you can better see the exposed "end" stud below the plywood and the right edge of the plywood,
square hole. To the right of this square hole, 1/4-inch to the right, is where the bottom brace of the tank
rests, on the plywood. So it is fully supported by contact with the plywood there.
___________________________
Here is a view from underneath the tank:
Photo: Here the view of the square hole reveals it recedes off the stud of the "end" stud, for the length of
the square hole or 5 inches, but the plywood closes back up again to the left of the hole, providing
sheathing stability everywhere else for the weight of the tank.
___________________________
C. Bottom Line
Is it safe to have the bottom rim of a tank lie a mere 1/4" inch from the edge of a square hole (5"x5") that was cut in the plywood top of a stand? Even if the square hole exposes the "end" stud beneath the hole, somewhat?
Long Explanation and Pictures:
A. The Tank and Stand
- I have an 80-gallon Deep Blue frag tank;
- The top of the tank has no plastic frame, but the bottom of the tank does have one;
- The tank has a corner overflow, in which two holes are drilled through the bottom of the tank;
- I am using a Rocket-Engineer design, DIY Stand;
- The stand has 2"x6" studs for the top frame;
- I have affixed a sheath of 3/4" plywood to the top of the stand;
- The tank sits on the plywood, which rests on the frame;
- The portion of the stand that lies to the right of the tank, extends 12 inches, beneath which is an extra compartment in the stand; and
- Here is a picture of the tank and stand, still under construction:

Photo: Note that the tank sits atop the left portion of the stand, with a right-side cabinet compartment beneath
the portion of the stand where there is no tank. This may help stabilize the sheathing over the stand, to compensate
for the plywood square hole that extends across the "airspace" of the "end" stud.
___________________________
B. The Square Hole in the Top of the Stand
- I have cut a 5" x 5" square hole in the plywood of the top of the stand, to allow the the corner overflow's drain pipes to pass through to the sump below;
- The plywood-window is cut beneath the right edge of the tank;
- Thus, most of the tank (about 43 inches of the the length of the tank) lies to the left of the square hole, supported by the 2x6" top frame beneath the plywood, which has no other holes in it;
- The plastic frame situated at the short "end" of the tank lies a mere 1/4" to the right of the 5" plywood square hole; and
- Here are some pictures of the square hole and the exposed end-stud:

Photo: Note the tan wood "line" in the picture above, to the right of the top bulkhead:
that is the exposed "end" stud below the plywood. This shows that the bottom rim of
the tank is resting on the plywood with a 1/4" to spare, but beyond that to the left, the
plywood is "vacated" off the stud below by 1 inch, leaving only 1/2 inch of the stud covered
by the plywood. This only occurs for 5 of 24 inches of the end run, i.e., the length of
the square hole. Above the square hole--or to the north of it--the plywood closes back up again,
over the entire area of the plywood top.
___________________________
A close up of the square hole:

Photo: Here you can better see the exposed "end" stud below the plywood and the right edge of the plywood,
square hole. To the right of this square hole, 1/4-inch to the right, is where the bottom brace of the tank
rests, on the plywood. So it is fully supported by contact with the plywood there.
___________________________
Here is a view from underneath the tank:

Photo: Here the view of the square hole reveals it recedes off the stud of the "end" stud, for the length of
the square hole or 5 inches, but the plywood closes back up again to the left of the hole, providing
sheathing stability everywhere else for the weight of the tank.
___________________________
C. Bottom Line
- I am guessing that this is okay because the actual contact point of the plastic frame is in contiguous contact with the plywood at all times;
- I imagine this is fine because, if you think about it, the entire outside perimeter of many tanks comes right to the edge of the stand--without even a 1/4" of plywood support extending beyond that perimeter, which we have here to the right of the square hole;
- But I would appreciate your thoughts because I could be quite wrong;
- Is this a safe move, or should I re-cut the top, to close up the exposure of plywood now existing over the "end stud"?; and
- In case you're wondering, I cut the square hole this way because it is easier to screw and unscrew the drain lines from the bulkheads in this area, should I ever need to do that.