UV sterilizer questions......

chwcdw

New member
Can anyone give me the low down on UV sterilizers?

I purchased my 90 gallon system used and it came with a Coralife 9 watt UV sterilizer. I have heard mixed opions but no real reasons why not to use one, and wanted to get more details.

Will it kill phyto and other beneficial creatures?

Should it only be used as needed or all the time or not at all?

What is it really intened to do?

Thanks for the help!
 
Ive just read a section in "The Conscientious Marine Aquarist: A Commonsense Handbook for Successful Saltwater Hobbyists" and it said basicly they are of little value for a mature reef tank that is properly maintained. though i think haveing one on a QT would be a good thing
 
A 9 watt UV sterilizer in that size tank will assist in maintaining water clarity - probably too small to have much of an impact on parasites.

UV sterilizers get hammered by some reefers because they don't descriminate about what they kill .. as such it can kill phyto and micro organisms that reefers want to feed their corals. I suspect those concerns are not all that valid since mature tanks tend to have more than enough of those critters and there is little evidence that corals can distinquish between dead/alive organisms when they feed.

UV's are generaly not effective at eliminating parasites like ich - but they can help reduce the population. Its possible to eliminate ich using a UV but flow rate necessary to eliminate ich would have to be about 5X the tank volume per hr which would require a pretty powerful UV to give the ich parasite sufficient dwell time (exposure) to the UV light.

If someone gave me a free UV I would have no concerns putting it on one of my reef tanks.

Hope this helps.
 
These are my reasons for not using mine:

1. Little benefit if you already use carbon/filter floss and QT
2. Extra bulbs to buy every six months
3. Extra energy being consumed by tank with small benefits
4. More equipment to clean
5. Could leak (happened to me once)

Those are my reasons for not using mine beyond what others said regarding their usefulness.
 
I run a 9W Turbo twist on my 75 and I really think it helps the clarity of my water. It kills Algae and adds ozone to my tank. The ozone may be a small amount compared to what ozone generators can make but I still believe it helps my tank. I have one on all my tanks even my freshwater Discus.

O2 + O + UV light -----> O3

Ozone is created when a molecule of oxygen is split by the energy of ultraviolet light or lightning. The oxygen atoms then bind with another oxygen atom to form O3.

This link will desribe more about Ozone specific to aquariums.
http://reefkeeping.com/issues/2006-03/rhf/index.php

I have not seen it kill any pods. My tank is overpopulated with them anyways. I ran a test a month ago to filter a container of pods through a UV and then into another container. All the pods lived so I chalk the pods dying up to rumor. Please feel free to conduct your own test but my results showed no dead pods. Now there is an argument that the UV kills a bacteria or algae that pods feed off and this what causes their death. So far I have not experienced this in my tank. I have pods breeding like crazy. I might just have to get a Mandarin or 6Line to keep it under control.

Again these are my experiences with using a UV on a Saltwater reef. I encourage you and anyone to conduct your own tests.
 
i dont use one on my reef
for some of the reasons already stated in this thread

one of the best LFS perhaps in the western US
recoms using one and have it on their 1000gal show tank - although i am sure they have research etc to back up their 'case' for using one - i still cant figure out if perhaps its bec they PREFER to sell them w/ every new tank set ups (it all adds up!) and at that shop it adds up REAL FAST!

regards
 
Where a UV unit is effective is if one has multiple tanks fed by a common sump. In that case they can help control a disease outbreak that occurs in one tank from spreading to the others. For single tanks I ignore them but if you already have one then hook in up if you wish.
 
I have been running a coralife 9 watt turbo twist for about 9 months now in my 55 gallon FOWLR tank. I bought it because I had a terrible ich outbreak in my tank. I tried everything to get rid of the ich so I wouldn't have to remove all of my fish to quaritine and leave the tank empty for 4-6 weeks untill all the ich died. So, I bought the UV light and was going to give that a shot before removing all of my fish. The thing worked beautiful. It took care of the big Ich outbreak within 2-3 weeks, and has kept the ich to a minimum since. I still see ich every now and then, but the UV keeps it under control.
 
I use uv sterlizers and think they are a good tool. They are not a substutute for good water quality nor a quarantine protocol nor effective treatment of disease.
A uv sterlilizer could not kill a pod unless one chose to live in there. It does kill waterborne bacteria and algae(including phytoplankton) pretty effectively.
It stops green water from excessive phyto and makes glass cleaning needs less frequent.If you keep animals that require more p[hyto than the sterlizer leaves in the water it can be easily supplemented.

A sterilizer's lethality depends upon the amount of radiation an organism receives relative to it's size. A higher wattage delivers more rads and so does longer exposure(slower flow or dwell time). Bacteria and algae are relatively small and smaller sterizer's are more effective against them.The bacteria effected are waterborne without much if any effect on the denitrifying bacteria in/on your substrate.

As for Ich, there are two kinds;cryptocaryon irritans,a protozoan parasite which is too large to be killed by the uv unless the strilizer is oversized and/or water passes through it very slowly. However,
the other ich,amyloodinium(sometimes called velvet) is a dinoflagellate algae. Amyloodinium is almost always fatal and destroys gill tissue very quickly. Otherwise healthy fish can sometimes shake off cryptocaryon. In a weakened state from cryptocaryon they do ,however, often fall to amyloodinium or secondary bacterial infection .
For clarity, A uv sterlizer is not a substittue for quarantine or treatment. It is a good supplemental piece of equipment and can help the health of your tank.
 
Back
Top