As someone who's studied GW's for some time now, I can say I'm disappointed personally in keeping one in captivity. Let me preface this by saying there are trade offs, in boosting education, and having people see one as an animal, not a monster. As E. O. Wilson has said, publicly and personally to me, the great white is the esscence of "sharkness" and is one of our last dragons.
My thought is to imprison one robs it of its free spirit and turns it into an attraction. Agreed, MBA has a stellar reputation as a research facility and has released a number of these comfortably back into the wild when the animal's health was only questioned, not endangered.
MBA is also a non-profit that employs dozens (maybe hundreds) of people and needs to support itself. All non-profits are in the business of staying in business. The money aspect is apparent in providing a 16 page pamphlet for $10 to learn about how the shark came to the tank.
I have worked at world class institutions- I'll even name them so I don't have anyone doubt it- like Notre Dame, MIT, I've worked for the Moody family that runs Moody Gardens in Galveston, and worked at New England Aq. To name a few, and currently have a grant in at National Geog.- To quote Ian Malcom, "You were so caught up in the excitement as to whether or not you could, you didn't stop to think if you should".
How will this shark's hunting be impacted?
How will it's sense of range and territory be effected?
How will it's size be impacted? (i know it's growing, but scientifically, one individual is not a "study" it's a model. The same that Michael Jordan can represent an understanding of the human species as a whole. I can say that my keeping a three stripe damsel is a scientific study to learn about a "seldom seen and hard to study organism")
I'm really not flaming anyone here, but I do disagree with the idea. And for the record, I do not eat animals- specifically because sea food has bycatch and shark finning, beef cattle are the cause for our rain forest drestruction, and factory farms pollute our waterways and earth. And I devote my entire life to preserving our oceans-
yeah, it's fun and all to have a gw in a tank, but considering the range on these animals is in the thousands of miles, one million gallons with no stimuli is a joke of a life.
I was at MBA the sunday before the shark was put in the tank. I'm glad that I wasn't there to see her in her cage. Divers belong in cages (well hopefully, if you're shark swimming...) not the sharks.
Just my opinion.