What killed my tang?

ECU_Pirate

New member
We added a Lamarck's angelfish last night, along with a lawnmower blenny and engineer goby. I followed a suggestion I’d read and heard about which was to put the fish in at night. The lights normally go off at 10:00 pm, but we turned them off around 7:00 pm, floated the bags in the tank while we went out to dinner (about 2 hours), came back and then drip acclimated the new fish one at a time before adding them to the tank.

This morning I woke up to check on the new inhabitants and found one of our already established fish, a Bristletooth tomini tang, dead on the sand. My first thought was that the Lamarck’s angel had attacked him. She is quite a bit bigger, about 3 times the size of the tang. Liveaquaria says they may chase small, docile planktivores such as anthias and wrasses, but I can't find anything online about how they do with tangs. My tang was always the one that did the occasional chasing, so I wouldn’t call him docile. I did notice that when we put the Lamarck's in she hid behind the rocks near my tang's territory. She’s there again this morning. My anthias is fine, and none of the other fish appear to be missing or dead.

But there are a few things I’d noticed just within the last few days that could point to something else. The tang seemed to be hanging out more at the back of the tank. We’ve had a hair algae outbreak, so I figured the tang was most likely picking algae off the glass where it’s hard for me to clean as well as the rocks in the back. He never did like strips of nori no matter how I presented them, but he would eat mysis shrimp cubes and Emerald Entrée which has both mysis shrimp and spirulina. He usually pooped in a front corner of the tank and I did notice that I hadn’t seen him pooping much. I also thought he looked slightly smaller than normal, but he ate daily. Certainly he didn’t starve to death, right? Could he have been sick? I’ve attached photos. Please let me know your thoughts as to what might’ve happened to him.

Edited to add - tank parameters are all good. No ammonia, no nitrites, nitrates less than 5 ppm.
 

Attachments

  • Tang 1.jpg
    Tang 1.jpg
    29.4 KB · Views: 4
  • Tang 2.jpg
    Tang 2.jpg
    36.6 KB · Views: 6
It's always hard to tell once dead, but it looks a bit thin to me. Had you noticed any weight loss, particularly pinching behind the head? That's always a really bad sign. I've had fish lose weight even though they appeared to be eating well. Some kind of underlying disease. My guess would be that adding the angel was coincidence.
 
I had a Lamark's for almost a year until an extended power outage did him (and several others) in. A model citizen, and one of the few that had no issue with my Yellow Tang. Sorry for your loss.
 
It's always hard to tell once dead, but it looks a bit thin to me. Had you noticed any weight loss, particularly pinching behind the head? That's always a really bad sign. I've had fish lose weight even though they appeared to be eating well. Some kind of underlying disease. My guess would be that adding the angel was coincidence.

Thanks for the reply. I didn't think to look for pinching behind the head, but I did think he looked a bit shrunken. I do agree now that the timing was most likely coincidental. Unless he was already headed downhill and the huge angelfish taking over his spot stressed him out and just sped up the process. I sure do miss my little guy!
 
I had a Lamark’s for almost a year until an extended power outage did him (and several others) in. A model citizen, and one of the few that had no issue with my Yellow Tang. Sorry for your loss.

Thank you. I almost feel bad now because after observing her for almost a week I see what a gentle giant she appears to be. She still hides when I walk up to the tank but if I sit in front of it VERY still and wait, she will come check me out. She doesn't bother anyone, nobody bothers her, and I pray it stays that way!
 
Last edited:
I bought a half chocolate mimic tang that died after 4 days. It was acting fine till the day before he died. It started hiding, then died the next morning. Its the only fish I had die on me, so I was upset.

Someone from the fish store told that they keep their tanks a 1.021 salinity and the acclimation period has to be at least 3 hours. I wasn't told that before adding the fish. I did acclimate him, but for maybe 2 hours. The LFS worker told me that they have issues with fish dying a few days after being sold. Not sure Ill buy from them again. Who knows if that's your reason or mine, but I found it interesting. It showed no signs of ich or marine velvet. It was eating well and wasn't breathing funny.

Mike
 
Back
Top