What species of clownfish would you call this?

elegance coral

They call me EC
<object width="480" height="385"><param name="movie" value="http://www.youtube.com/v/nGYkxqZ7J_c?fs=1&hl=en_US"></param><param name="allowFullScreen" value="true"></param><param name="allowscriptaccess" value="always"></param><embed src="http://www.youtube.com/v/nGYkxqZ7J_c?fs=1&hl=en_US" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" allowscriptaccess="always" allowfullscreen="true" width="480" height="385"></embed></object>
 
Out of Fiji and Tonga they are yellow tailed. The nice thing about the yellow tailed ones is they seem to hold their color in captivity.
 
Well, it seems unanimous. I commented on the video about 6 months ago. I told him the video was beautiful but those were chrysopterus not clarkii. He responded by saying he did further research and confirmed his ID of clarkii. I guess the video stands as is until when/if he learns the difference between these two species.
 
Definitely chrysopterus. I had a pair from Guam which had the white tails. They did seem to lose some color after awhile.
 
I was curious why you were asking such a question. I always fancied you a pretty informed guy in the realm of clownfish and anemones. Had me boggled as to why you were unsure of the species.
 
Thanks. Ya, I knew what it was, and I knew that you and other here, would know what it was. That's why I posted the thread. I didn't want to mention the species of fish, because I didn't want it to appear as though I influenced the responses. If he reads this thread, he'll know everyone came up with chrysopterus because that is the correct ID for those fish.
 
Good to know your not going senile. The clown geek club isn't exactly beating members off with sticks to begin with.
 
A big thanks to you EC, for help with this video identification! (and EC, the nice email telling us about your post here to help id it.) Another big thanks to all of you who took the time to watch it and help to id it as well. The consensus... it's not A. clarkii but rather A. chrysopterus. So we are pulling it to correct the title name and text... so watch for the replacement of "Orange-fin Anemonefish Amphiprion chrysopterus sp."

Here's a little background...
When EC wrote to us previously, we did re-researched this fish trying to determine if it was in fact an A. clarkii or A. chrysopterus, or what. However we were still in the dark.

In the book "Field Guide to Anemonefishes and their Host Sea Anemones", by Dr. Daphne G. Fautin and Gerald R. Allen, it describes the A. chrysopterus as "Brown to nearly black with two white or bluish-whie bars and a whitish caudal fin... all other fins are yellow-orange, but fish from Melanesia have black pelvic and anal fins." They describe A. chrysopterus and A. allardi both as having white tails. Only two species described, with the type of patterning seen in the video, have yellow tails, the A. clarkii and A. bicinctus. We had eliminated A. bicinctus since it doesn't have an expanded headbar characteristic of that species.

Recently EC suggested that tail color might not be a good identifier. So based on his recommendation and all of your input here, we're off and running to adjust that very cool clown video! (We are also emailing Dr. Fautin with pics and link to the vid to see if she thinks it's a color morph, a subspecies, or what... We'll let you know if and what she says!)

I do think it's a very cool clownfish video and hope you all enjoy it too!
 
Most definetely mertensii. S. Mertensii along with H. crispa are the two most commonly seen species hosting A. chrysopterus.
 
Last edited:
A big thanks to you EC, for help with this video identification! (and EC, the nice email telling us about your post here to help id it.) Another big thanks to all of you who took the time to watch it and help to id it as well. The consensus... it's not A. clarkii but rather A. chrysopterus. So we are pulling it to correct the title name and text... so watch for the replacement of "Orange-fin Anemonefish Amphiprion chrysopterus sp."

Here's a little background...
When EC wrote to us previously, we did re-researched this fish trying to determine if it was in fact an A. clarkii or A. chrysopterus, or what. However we were still in the dark.

In the book "Field Guide to Anemonefishes and their Host Sea Anemones", by Dr. Daphne G. Fautin and Gerald R. Allen, it describes the A. chrysopterus as "Brown to nearly black with two white or bluish-whie bars and a whitish caudal fin... all other fins are yellow-orange, but fish from Melanesia have black pelvic and anal fins." They describe A. chrysopterus and A. allardi both as having white tails. Only two species described, with the type of patterning seen in the video, have yellow tails, the A. clarkii and A. bicinctus. We had eliminated A. bicinctus since it doesn't have an expanded headbar characteristic of that species.

Recently EC suggested that tail color might not be a good identifier. So based on his recommendation and all of your input here, we're off and running to adjust that very cool clown video! (We are also emailing Dr. Fautin with pics and link to the vid to see if she thinks it's a color morph, a subspecies, or what... We'll let you know if and what she says!)

I do think it's a very cool clownfish video and hope you all enjoy it too!

You are very welcome. It's impressive that you would take the time to research this issue and insure your ID is correct. Most people wouldn't care.

Dr. Fautin's book is a great reference. Probably the best available. We have to remember that it was written about 20 years ago though. The ocean is a huge place, and there have been many new discoveries in the past 20 years. Like yellow tailed chrysopterus, and A. polymnus using M. doreensis as a host in the wild. Anything that we've learned in the past 20 years, will not show up in her book.

The video is amazing! I'm not going to admit how many times I've watched it. :lol: I'd love to have those clowns and that anemone. Unfortunately, both species are rare in captivity.
 
You are very welcome. It's impressive that you would take the time to research this issue and insure your ID is correct. Most people wouldn't care.

Dr. Fautin's book is a great reference. Probably the best available. We have to remember that it was written about 20 years ago though. The ocean is a huge place, and there have been many new discoveries in the past 20 years. Like yellow tailed chrysopterus, and A. polymnus using M. doreensis as a host in the wild. Anything that we've learned in the past 20 years, will not show up in her book.

The video is amazing! I'm not going to admit how many times I've watched it. :lol: I'd love to have those clowns and that anemone. Unfortunately, both species are rare in captivity.

That is a great point Eric about the Fautin and Allen book. It is a great starting point but it is dated. For example I have seen several examples, such as dive videos, of clowns associating with anemone species not listed as natural hosts in the book. Some of these off the top of my head are bicinctus living with haddoni anemones and a photo of a young allardi sharing a H. magnifica with akallopisos. Also of course recently described species such as A. barberi are not described in the book.
 
Back
Top