Whats with my red planet?

[OneReef]

It is well know that the lower the light with the RP the more green you keep, and the higher light, the more red/pink you get with the green fading

 

[Dana42078]

Nope, not offended at all. Yes I use photoshop to correct the white balance. Do I over saturate my photos. No. I strive to give the best representation of my corals as I see them in person. Anyone who has seen my tank in person will tell you that's exactly how it looks.

 

[6Speed]

It is well know that the lower the light with the RP the more green you keep, and the higher light, the more red/pink you get with the green fading

I've read that multiple times online, but I've experienced just the opposite. Very weird. My buddy has a very large planet colony and his is very low in his tank and not centered under the light (250w halide + 2 T5's) His is all red/pink without any hint of green. He then fragged a few pieces and placed them up near the very top directly under the light and it started developing green. I got one of those frags and placed it under my LED right in the center of the light up high in my tank and it turned even more/mostly green with just a hint of red!

 

[Dana42078]

As far as dosing. I really don't dose that much. I do water changes every three weeks. Twards the end of the third week I'll test an if something is off I try and correct it. For alk I've been using baking soda, for calcium I use kent liquid cal, and for mag I use some liquid mag...can't remember the name off the top of my head and I'm at work.

My 46g just had its second birthday June 1st.

 

[sahin]

Nope, not offended at all. Yes I use photoshop to correct the white balance. Do I over saturate my photos. No. I strive to give the best representation of my corals as I see them in person. Anyone who has seen my tank in person will tell you that's exactly how it looks.

Thank you for not taking offence. Generally, T5 lit tanks tend not to have as intense colour. BUT, having looked at the photos again, on my laptop at home, the colour doesnt appear as saturated as it did at my work computer.

As far as dosing. I really don't dose that much. I do water changes every three weeks. Twards the end of the third week I'll test an if something is off I try and correct it. For alk I've been using baking soda, for calcium I use kent liquid cal, and for mag I use some liquid mag...can't remember the name off the top of my head and I'm at work.

My 46g just had its second birthday June 1st.

Do you feel that the age of the tank makes for better colours as opposed to say when the tank was 3-4 months old?

 

[Dana42078]

Thank you for not taking offence. Generally, T5 lit tanks tend not to have as intense colour. BUT, having looked at the photos again, on my laptop at home, the colour doesnt appear as saturated as it did at my work computer.



Do you feel that the age of the tank makes for better colours as opposed to say when the tank was 3-4 months old?

I'm not totally sure. If I were to make an educated guess I'd say yes.

As far as its color goes. I've seen all sorts of RP in a lot of diff ppls tanks and Not two have looked the same.

 

[Dana42078]

one of my favorites

Thanks

Guess i can add that i feed TLF reef snow....my lights are on from 11am-12 two bulbs, 12-7:30pm all 4 bulbs, 7:30pm-8:30pm 2 bulbs

 

[frankyrivera]

I have two red planets in my tank both at the same level one is all green with light pink and the other is all red with some green lol same piece Same tank same spot two different colors. Who knows sometimes lol

 

[dvanacker]

never seen one with blue tips before....

 

[Dana42078]

NOTHING!:lolspin: Its growing great, figured i'd share a pic i took today....this started from a half inch frag i got free from my favorite LFS.

Day 3

Today:crazy1:

never seen one with blue tips before....

Darryl where do you see blue? They look bright white to me.:headwally:

 

[Dana42078]

I dont see why my balls are being busted here. I have my photoshop set at 3 for saturation...you want saturation here....but thats not what i do with my photos. All my photo's are shot in raw and simply converted with photoshop. I really dont even mess with them unless the white balance needs to be corrected. Sorry some feel i shopped my photo but i didn't do anything to it other than convert the file. And like i said my saturation is set at 3!!! Give me a freakin break.

I really dont care but whatever. Think what ya want

 

[sahin]

Try not to take offense. Darryl is a genuine reefkeeper. I suppose what I would say is that if one posts photos there will be criticism, postive and negative, or questions asked etc if photos appear a bit more colourful than one expects.

It might be that due to your monitor and colour profile setup on your software and computer, colour appear at normal saturation and look fine; but on other peoples monitors colour may appear more saturated.

Like I said the other day, at work when I viewed both your photos, the second photo appeared a lot more colour saturated.

In any event, the coral has definately coloured up. :beer:

Do you have a build thread somewhere? I searched your name but couldnt find one here on RC. I would like to know more about your system. Thanks.

 

[Dana42078]

Try not to take offense. Darryl is a genuine reefkeeper. I suppose what I would say is that if one posts photos there will be criticism, postive and negative, or questions asked etc if photos appear a bit more colourful than one expects.

It might be that due to your monitor and colour profile setup on your software and computer, colour appear at normal saturation and look fine; but on other peoples monitors colour may appear more saturated.

Like I said the other day, at work when I viewed both your photos, the second photo appeared a lot more colour saturated.

In any event, the coral has definately coloured up. :beer:

Do you have a build thread somewhere? I searched your name but couldnt find one here on RC. I would like to know more about your system. Thanks.

I know Darryl is a SPS god. I'm subscribed to his build thread. That's what kinda made me on edge coming from him. If there's anyone to impress it would be him I'd wanna impress.

As far as a build thread. I've always been to scared to start one on this site because my tank is still young and doesn't even compare to most peoples on here. Don't think I'd have to many followers.

Im in the middle of changing the two tanks I have now. My 46g bow front which this piece is in is getting changed to a 45g cube and my 20g mantis tank is going to be a 40g breeder. Maybe I'll start those threads when I get a chance.

As far as the tank is right now.

46g bowfront
Ati 4 bulb fixture and ati bulbs
Reef octo hob skimmer along with running a bio wheel
No sump
Monthly 7g water changes
Hydor power heads

SG 1.025
Cal 450
Mag 1350
Ph 8.1

Everything else I TRY to keep at zero which doesn't always work.

The tank has been up 2 years as of June 1.

I'm sorry for getting bent outa shape. Kinda woke up in a crappy mood. Thanks for the support.

 

[Moser]

I dont see why my balls are being busted here. I have my photoshop set at 3 for saturation...you want saturation here....but thats not what i do with my photos. All my photo's are shot in raw and simply converted with photoshop. I really dont even mess with them unless the white balance needs to be corrected. Sorry some feel i shopped my photo but i didn't do anything to it other than convert the file. And like i said my saturation is set at 3!!! Give me a freakin break.

I really dont care but whatever. Think what ya want

I have the same coral..... With blue tips!.

Mo

 

[Dana42078]

That made me lol thanks

 

[Reefer1225]

I know Darryl is a SPS god. I'm subscribed to his build thread. That's what kinda made me on edge coming from him. If there's anyone to impress it would be him I'd wanna impress.

As far as a build thread. I've always been to scared to start one on this site because my tank is still young and doesn't even compare to most peoples on here. Don't think I'd have to many followers.

Im in the middle of changing the two tanks I have now. My 46g bow front which this piece is in is getting changed to a 45g cube and my 20g mantis tank is going to be a 40g breeder. Maybe I'll start those threads when I get a chance.

As far as the tank is right now.

46g bowfront
Ati 4 bulb fixture and ati bulbs
Reef octo hob skimmer along with running a bio wheel
No sump
Monthly 7g water changes
Hydor power heads

SG 1.025
Cal 450
Mag 1350
Ph 8.1

Everything else I TRY to keep at zero which doesn't always work.

The tank has been up 2 years as of June 1.

I'm sorry for getting bent outa shape. Kinda woke up in a crappy mood. Thanks for the support.

Looks awesome, Dana42078! As long as you know what it really looks like and like it, then who cares what anyone else says. I admire a lot of people's tanks here, including dvanacker, but I think I'll set myself up for disappointment and drive myself crazy if I try to mimic other people's accomplishments. So, I just take it as a fun hobby, try to learn from others, and make the best with what I got. The only person I try to impress is myself.

Keeps us posted on growth. My RP doesn't even come close to your growth/color in that time span. So, nice work!

 

[dvanacker]

I know Darryl is a SPS god. I'm subscribed to his build thread. That's what kinda made me on edge coming from him. If there's anyone to impress it would be him I'd wanna impress.

I don't think anyone knows enough to be called that. We are all just a bad batch of salt or an equipment failure away from a complete wipeout.

Sorry but I didnt read the whole thread. I was not really being sarcastic.....to me the tips do look light blue. If you say they are white than perhaps your whitebalance is skewed a little blue. I don't think the you jacked the saturation. Whitebalance is not the easiest to nail down and is the most important in taking a true to life picture. Even I can screw up the white balance from time to time.

But this is just a friendly critique maybe on the photo, not the quality of the coral. It probably is just as bright as the original picture....red planet is a bright acro. In fact if you adjusted white balance till those tips are white I bet it would show the redplanet as more red.

 

[Dana42078]

I don't think anyone knows enough to be called that. We are all just a bad batch of salt or an equipment failure away from a complete wipeout.

Sorry but I didnt read the whole thread. I was not really being sarcastic.....to me the tips do look light blue. If you say they are white than perhaps your whitebalance is skewed a little blue. I don't think the you jacked the saturation. Whitebalance is not the easiest to nail down and is the most important in taking a true to life picture. Even I can screw up the white balance from time to time.

But this is just a friendly critique maybe on the photo, not the quality of the coral. It probably is just as bright as the original picture....red planet is a bright acro. In fact if you adjusted white balance till those tips are white I bet it would show the redplanet as more red.

Thanks. I will have to play with my pics more i guess. I mean im still getting used to using my camera and the software. Not claiming to be a professional.
I appriciate your feed back and will take it in and try harder next time. Thanks for looking and sharing your knowledge.

Dana

 

[myroom]

stunning wow incredible growth and color