Where will LED be in 2 years?

Hopefully there will be some sound modules to go with the storm simulations. I would expect in 2 years for there to be more selection in LED setups similar to the AI Sol. The price will prob come down too. AI Sols can already burn corals so performance wise they probably aren't going to get much better than the AI Sols. Maybe more options on sizes. LEDs are the way to go these days.
 
I predict the next LED fixtures will come with the smell of the reef, smell of fish poo, and noise of the waves crashing!

Can you imagine real lightning with real sounds!?!? That would be SCHWEEET!
 
You should spend some time researching proper light acclimation and you wont have the bleaching and melting problems. Why would you want to melt an LPS on the sand bed?


LOL

I know plenty about light acclimation. I figured coming from a 150w MH to the Sunpower, things wouldn't react as harsh as they did. I had the SPS at the top of my 24 gallon Nano Cube right under the 150w Phoenix bulb.

When I switched tanks and lighting, I placed everything in the tank at least half way down. Most was on the sand however.

I still ticked off some SPS and my LPS took a little while to come around.

I would never intentionally bleach my corals. To assume that like you did, is ludicrous.

I simply stated that the other individual probably doesn't have a great setup if they think that 4x39w isn't enough light. It probably isn't if it is a cheap fixture.
 
Hopefully, what we'll see in the future is an increased focus on spectral composition as opposed to brute force. I've had more than one highly spirited discussion with reefers that are PAR-obsessed without asctually understanding what PAR measures. The critters we keep do not respond equally to the full range of the PAR spectrum (~400nm - 700nm). Put a lightsource outputting 1200 PAR of yellow light on your tank and get back to me with the results.

As was pointed out earlier, LED's by nature are very narrow band emitters. That's not natural and neither particularly helpful. Our critters have specific (and somewhat varied species-to-species) spectral requirements that align with the zooxanthellae they host and, in some cases, the organism's own biochemistry. Aligning a palette of narrow-band emitters to those needs is not only impractical but probably unachievable.

The LED industry is focused on manufacturing environmental lighting --- warehouses, homes, stores, signage. We appropriate their devices for our (unintended) use. They focus, naturally, on 'white' light. And as was pointed out they do this by doping narrow-band LED's with phosphors --- exactly as is done with T5's and other fluroescent lights. By combining different phosphors, manufacturers give us our different T5 'colors' (MH uses different combinations of gases to sculpt the spectrum).

LED manufacturers can do the same thing. They are just not motivated (yet) to do so. They could give us all manner of 'whites' with spectral compositions that compliment our tanks' needs if they so chose. So for me, it's not about chasing the ultimate high-PAR LED as much as it is giving us a greater range of choices when it comes to spectral composition. Look at the spectral graphs of the three 'whites' from which we can choose and compare them to output plots from various T5 and/or MH bulbs. You'll see what I mean.
 
Once I see that the bulbs do last 7 years or whatever they claim without issue I would consider them, but only if the price drops. Today I would only buy one if they had a warranty on parts and labor for however long they claim the bulb will last. If they are selling me a product that they claim will last at least 5 years backing that up with a 100% warranty should not be a problem.

But with my tank being in the basement and living in MI i actually like the heat my MH's produce, saves me from having to run the heaters as much and warms up the fish room to a comfortable temp, but I realize this is not the case for everyone and some of you do have heat issues.

This is just like all other technology, jump in early and say I have the newest stuff, pay and arm and a leg for it and basically be the companies beta testers. Or wait until they get all the complaints about what they did wrong, let them perfect then buy it cheaper.

It's kind of like buying a new car in the first year it is produced. There will be issues with it that were not caught in testing, and they will be addressed and fixed by the next model year.
 
Back
Top