which of these 3 anthias combination?

[geaux xman]

which of the 3 combination would you do? i have 4 carberryi in QT and looking to add some more. for 180g tank.

1) 10 carberryi anthias

2) 8 carberryi anthias and 3 lyretail(2female/1male)

3) 6 carberryi and 6 lyretail

 

[snorvich]

Or 7 carberryi and 3 evansi. Which is almost what I have which is 5 evansi and 8 carberryi.

 

[djze]

don't mix the cranberryi with the lyretail witch was my mistake also in a 180 one single lyretail killed off 10 barletts and cranberryi male lyretails can be very agressive towards other anthias

 

[geaux xman]

nice. as of this post, theres 4 votes for each.

then a djze stating that his male lyretail killed off to 10 barletts and carberryi's.

 

[davocean]

I have Lyretails and caryberri's, and one dispar, no aggression at all, great combo.
Carberri's are a little tougher to keep colors brightest, lyretails scream w/ color.
My dispar has been surprisingly cool too, and super bright colors.
All eat great.