Why are prices so different between vendors?

SereneAquatic

New member
Is there a reason why the same type of fish can have widely different prices among vendors? It doesn't even seem to be that the vendor is consistently high or low in prices... they are all over the board.

Do vendors just change prices based on what they have in stock at the moment?

I attached a screenshot of prices I found this week on a variety of species. The green blocks indicate the low price for each... and some are very much higher.

:uhoh3:
 

Attachments

  • Price Sheet.jpg
    Price Sheet.jpg
    74.6 KB · Views: 3
interesting to note that the two with the majority of the lowest prices also offer a 2 week guarantee.
 
On top of what others said, it will also depend on for how long the vendor is keeping the fish before putting it up for sale. If I remember correctly LA keeps the fish for at least 2 weeks before putting them up for sale. I know this because I asked LA about a certain fish sometime ago and they said they recently got a batch of that fish but they are under stress reduction protocol and should appear in stock in couple of weeks. Some vendors do not do this and would sell the fish as soon as they arrive. Longer the fish is kept at their facility, higher the price (since they need to feed it and account for the fish that die during this procedure). Most vendors that offer "no-questions" 2 weeks guarantee on their fish do this, since it increases the odds of fish surviving..
 
Pricing is a detailed strategy. Taking into account labor, equipment, sourcing location, freight, taxes etc etc, list is huge and commodity dependent. What works for one may or may not work with another. Then they may have a strategy of being the lowest priced, anything is possible. I would say the strongest influencer is cost of the fish, then you add all the other stuff on top, then determine what margin you are looking to capture.
 
These prices are great, double that in Canada....except for clams which are cheap here...
They get what they can, that's just business....I seen 40 buck differences between two related stores with 20 miles of each other....
 
+1 for all of the above. It's because we live in a free market. Everyone's costs are different for all the reasons listed, so they charge differently. Or maybe they offer more, such as guarantees, follow up advice, or the store does some kind of QT and /or treatment.

One thing that wasn't mentioned was: because they can. A store that lives in an area with wealthy shoppers may mark up prices in part because it won't deter purchases, if done properly.

Conversely, I've also heard that stores that experience high theft tend to raise prices to compensate. I don't think that applies here.
 
Like any shopper, your best defense is shopping around and get to know your prices.
Example, yesterday, store 1, fist size golden hammer on a mount was $179.00, yet at store 2, just 20 minutes away, the same piece was $79.00. They way the were both mounted and tagged, indicates to me that the source was likely the same.
 
Back
Top