Not sure if someone has brought this up already, but is the MH and VHO retrofitted into a canopy or are they in a fixture? If this is a retrofit, what kind of reflector are you using?
Also, how close to the water do you have the MH bulb?
You might also want to try measuring the par with a lux meter, if you have one, or borrow one from someone if you don't.
At the very least, I would try to have the bulb and/or the ballast exchanged for a new one before the warranty expired. Bad bulbs and ballasts do happen...