why I don't use filter socks or filters:

Sk8r

Staff member
RC Mod
fuge.
Pods, (amphi and cope), mysis, bits of sponge, worms---and occasional stupid small fish.

Ways I do clean my water: I will use a wad of blue/white filter floss if things get kicked up: it comes out after a single day, and I always wince at the loss of pods.

Now, mind, this is MY style of tank: doesn't make it the only way in the universe to run a tank---tthere are, for instance, the lovely, white-sand, low-nutrient TOTM (tank of the month) types...which I pretty well know I will never have. My tank has patches of very untidy stuff. I run sps, lps, small fish, lots of fuge life. I don't have ich, don't have disease, do have bubblealgae and cyano now and again (sunlight from kitchen window)---it's NOT a pristine hyper-controlled tank: it looks more like a fuge with corals--- ;) and, yep, you can see film algae here and there before my blenny gets it.
But it's alive. It crawls, at night. And the fish have a lot of spare hours occupation chasing pods and mysis. I have a lot of spare hours occupation scraping coralline off my glass.

This isn't a critique of the pristine tank. But newbies, particularly fresh-water-trained newbies, walking into a store with all those super filter displays and trying to buy the right equipment for their tank do need to know two things:
1. any filter is a pita when it comes to creating nitrate pockets: rock and sand is far the better and produces NO nitrate pockets.
2. you pay in pods for filter socks. They're good to have on hand, however. In case you move a rock and kick up goo.
3. white sand is a choice, among many choices. Depends on your style.
But stay away from filters unless you keep big fish in a fowlr. The TOTMs are a whole different pursuit, and you need to do a lot of research and study and gather know-how to do those. They also require time and dedication, and a small smattering of good luck with a large dose of really good set-up.

HTH...and makes people feel better about their own little patch of cyano. Doesn't make you a bad reefer. Just means your tank is like a lot of other tanks.
Here's mine: 54g bow with 30g sump containing 20g fuge. This is about 12 mos after the Big Move and re-setup.

PICT0042.jpg


Oh---that white sand? I've moved that out: it kept blowing and bugging my corals. I'm going to install coarser, less pristine-looking medium grade aragonite, which FINALLY has come in at my lfs. I pick it up today.

Paint my background? Naw---I just let coralline and red algae take it. It would anyway.
 
I like the purest approach as well. I am still a baby in the hobby but it makes sense to me that the old "KISS" principal applies to this as well.

Keep It Simple Stupid :-)
 
Water flowing fast everywhere: gushing under the rock on a bare-bottom, going in a straight shot through the sump from the overflow, past the skimmer, though the chaeto bird-net cage, back to the return pump.


Simple is good.
 
i do the same and it is working very well for me. nol mechanical filtration at all except my skimmer
 
i use one but do clean it about every 4 days....i like it because it catches so much particulate it amazes me...and i dont think i get many pods in there since i highly doubt pods swim so high in the tank as to be next to my overflow...i doubt they make it above the rocks anyway since the current is so strong...but to use one you have to be very DILIGENT in cleaning it, no forgetting about it and letting it clog up and make a nitrate pocket. i usually clean it when the water level inside the sock becomes higher than the water level of the surrounding water in my sump (which means its basically having a hard time filtering) i also used it as a place to put my GFO to get rid of my CRAZY high phosphates when i first started..since i had to change the media often anyway it was the perfect place because i knew all the water would eventually make its way through the filter sock and the GFO

HTH
 
oh and as far as stupid fish, my overflow has a grated cover over it so even my smallest fish couldnt make it through
 
Back
Top