Go captive breed all the time, the fish acclimate much better, usually has less chances for parasites and other diseases, and in my experience they seem a bit less aggressive than wild caught fish. Also we need to support the captive breed industry so they can expand their efforts to try to raise more types of fish for us to choose over wild caught fish. I would be willing to pay more for a captive raise fish and we as hobbyist should be asking our fish stores to clearly support this approach. Over time , I can see many locations being restricted from catching wild caught fish for our industry. We need to support captive breed /raised industry to hopefully have them fund more reseach on how to expand the efforts to different types of fish similiar to what is happening with buying live coral.