yellow cucumbers

sly fox

Premium Member
in shimeks marine inverts book it says that he did not know of nukes from yellow cuc's... are they ok to have in a crab free tank?
 
This one didn't nuke tank, when died after a toxic tank crash:
goldenatworkAug25.jpg

Corals survived its death in hospital container, with some carbon, of course, just in case.

in store it looked like this:
goldencukeasinstoreAug7a.jpg


Only protect heaters!
yellowheater2.jpg


I had it with small emerald crabs - no problem.

The substrate should be not so coarse, as on my pictures.
Love this creature!
 
In my case, crash started, when I was at home and took few hours.

My tank had toxic crash after death of two not cucumbers, with followed evisceration on dark grey with silver grey sand-sifting cucumber. I removed bodies as soon, as I seen them, and moved all still alive in any containers at the hand (luckily, I have a big tank to take water from).

Yellow cucumber and pink-green filter feeding cucumber died on the next day, despite multiple water changes and constantly changed carbon. Skin lesion, as from toxic gases, no evisceration.

Corals are alive and well from the same tank, including xenia.
Sorry for gruesome description.
 
We had a tank crash a day or two after we stopped seeing our 1" yellow sea cuke... xenia, tubipora, zoas... all got sick and quickly diminished until they died.
 
Ron was talking about the small filter feeder Colochirus robustus. Dendro, your's is a detritus sweeper, looks like a Stichopus.
 
I thought, that I'm buying Colochirus robustus :D
Sits on the top, small, pure yellow, spiky...

BTW, there should be the yellow filter feeding Pentacta cucumber - P. lutea, may be as safe, as the pink-green was. Never seen them, although.

gholland:
Do you have a photo of your cucumber - how it looks in LFS and when expanded? To be able to recognize it in the store.
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=11752464#post11752464 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by dendro982
I thought, that I'm buying Colochirus robustus :D
Sits on the top, small, pure yellow, spiky...

That's the problem with short descriptions - often they can apply to several species. A lot of current taxonomic research goes into cleaning the mess left by original descriptions that weren't descriptive enough!
:lol:

Take a look at the feeding tentacles. Colochirus has ones with tree-like branching. The ones on Stichopus look like sections of cauliflower. That's a really big clue as to how they feed.
 
Pretty sure mine was the Colochirus robustus... can't swear it was the cuke that wiped out the tank, but the timing is very suspect... enough so that I won't buy another one.
 
That why I'm asking about photos from keepers - of cucumber contracted (as it frequently seen in the stores, for visual recognition) and open - to see is it filter feeding or sand sifting. There should be difference even between yellow Colochirus and yellow Pentacta. Love Pentactas - does anybody knows their maximal size?
 
Here's mine, not sure on the species. Feeders branch and he filters the sand better than anything else in the tank. Had it for over a year now and it's around 7" long.

76089616.jpg
 
ive had my yellow for about a year now with no problems ......it does a awesome job on the sand ...

i have in the past tried to id him but have always come up empty ...he looks just like the pics posted here in this thread ...
 
Nope, no real problems with it. Every now and then it moves a coral around but that's it. Had it almost two years now.
 
Thank you, Wrench!

crystl: Do you have a photo? For all of us - for visual recognition, especially, when in store :)

Maximal length and additional feedings (if ever) will help too.

Mine contracted was min 3", max extended ~7", normally ~4.5".
2 shrimp pellets for bottom feeders as an additional feeding - had only shallow sand bed in nano tank. In store I thought, that it was filter feeder...
 
Back
Top