2 part vs ca reactor

nbsdsailor

New member
Hey guys, I am new to SPS and I am in the process of turning my 75g mix reef into a sps dominant. One question that I have is what is the difference between dosing 2 part with peristaltic pumps vs a Ca reactor? Is there more benefits to running a reactor? Currently I just test and dose by hand once a week, but my alk consumption is already jumping up.
 
If you are only dosing once a week right now I would just stick with 2 part. You can up your manual dosing schedule until its too much work and then just add a couple dosing pumps when the demand is there. This is an inexpensive and simple way to dose. A reactor will work too but it is a much higher start up cost and more complicated to get set up. I think reactors are better suited for large systems.
 
i agree..after several unsuccessful attempts with a ca reactor on my 180 i decided to start dosing to part 6 months ago. i can buy enough two part solution that will last me a year for about $150..when you compare that to the initial cost of a ca reactor (approx $500 or more), i can go three years dosing two part to just break even.
 
I use 2part from brs, and absolutley love it. They even have the reef calculators there for you too on the home page. Just type in your total gallons in water volume, then type in your current calcium, alk, ph, magnesiums levels and then the levels you want them to be at. It then tells you how to much add to reach your goal.
 
I think automated dosing vs Ca reactor accomplish the same thing.....a little ca, buffer, trace into the tank continuously....just depends on which agent you prefer...
 
Yea but u don't need to dose mag on a pump right? Just test and dose every couple weeks? I rarely need to dose mag compared to Ca and Alk.
 
Yea but u don't need to dose mag on a pump right? Just test and dose every couple weeks? I rarely need to dose mag compared to Ca and Alk.

agreed. I just test every week and dose a quart when I get down to 1300 which is maybe once every couple of months. Weekly water changes with coralife helps keep it up.

2 part has been working well for me so far. I'm starting to get nervous because I'm up to dosing 100ml / day now. I'm going through a lot pretty quickly.
 
I was useing BRS 2 part with great results. But now I set up a ca reactor and it works great as well. Groth has been the same with both.
 
thanks for input guys, I ended up buying 2 BRS dosing pumps. I don't think I need to dose Mg right now. I don't have a problem with precipitation of alk and Ca.
 
I'm starting to get nervous because I'm up to dosing 100ml / day now. I'm going through a lot pretty quickly.

I wouldn't worry too much. I'm just assuming you have a lot of coral using it pretty fast right? They recommend 1ml/gal and 1+ml/gal for demanding aquariums. :thumbsup:
 
If your mag is chronically low, your sps be unhappy way before you experience issues with precipitation. I've had birdsnest and undatas rtn with mag less than 1000 before I understood the importance of dosing mag too. Don't forget magnesium is the third most abundant element in ocean water and plays an important role in the interaction of alkalinity and calcium.

I don't put much stock in the 1ml/gal dosing guideline. I'm dosing almost 400mls a day of ca in my 150g water system. I have lots of sps, including a 18" monti cap. If I were starting with what I have now, I might opt for a ca reactor, but I started with no corals and worked my way up, so dosing made lots of sense back then.

Whether dosing or using a reactor, both methods of adding supplements require consistent water testing to ensure appropriate concentrations. The beauty of dosing is the simplicity. If my water tests lower than 400 ca, or my alk below 9, or mag below 1300, I add minutes to the time the dosing pump runs. Because my corals are constantly growing, the amount of supplement required is continually increasing over time. And I can alter the dosing on any of those three items independently of the others.

I also am not concerned with dosing the exact same quantity of alk and mag as ca. I dose more ca than alk and way more of those than mag. In approximate ratios, my tank requires roughly 5x ca, 4x alk and 1x mag to keep my water "in the zone".
 
Back
Top