I have a simular size tank but it is a little smaller than yours it is 36wx30tx60L and I have the following in it 2 4" niger trgs,5"blueline trg,3" undulated trg,a very fast growing 6" Gray trg,12" Queen trg,4"hummu trg,3" titan trg,5" pinktail trg courtsey of danorth(thanks Dan),8" lionfish,10" Stellatus puf,7" Sapo puf,6" sohal tng,6" R D S Sailfin tang,5" Naso Tang,6" Passer angel,8" Maculoses angel,6"queen angel,6" mexican Lunare wrasse. I just moved this tank to my new house and lost aMiniatus grouper and a Saddle grouper in the move very bummed had both of those fish for over a year and they were getting very big and fat.I hope to replace them soon.Yes I know my tank is overstocked but I prefer a tank that way.For all of you negative people I will be separting a lot of these fish between a new 300 gal tank and a 125 gal tank and my 100 gal reef, This trying to settle in first. I think your original stocklist would have been fine,just be prepared to divide them up later when they get big.Ithink a heavier stocked tank will help with there different temperments.Just my thoughts.