Ok, here's the situation; I bought three B/W Ocellaris clowns back in August of 2006. They were all about the same size when I got them. Over the next couple of months they started to work out the pecking order and their sizes changed accordingly. So now I have three different sized clowns. As usual the biggest clown would pick on the middle clown and the middle clown would pick on the smallest clown, but recently the biggest and the smallest clowns have been inseparable and the middle sized clown has been off cowering in a corner of the tank. Could it be that the female has chosen the smaller clown as a mate instead of the medium sized clown? Should I remove one of the clowns and if so which one? The big clown and the medium clown aren't that far apart in size, could I have two females?
A question for the experts.
- Thread starter 1jared1
- Start date
Chupacabras
New member
In the tank environment, harems rarely work out with clowns... you're seeing normal behavior for a pair with a sexually immature third.
Remove one of the smaller ones before it's too late (I'd take out the smallest as clowns take their male to female sexual cue from hormones in the water [the current theory anyways] so you shouldn't have two female false percs in there).
Remove one of the smaller ones before it's too late (I'd take out the smallest as clowns take their male to female sexual cue from hormones in the water [the current theory anyways] so you shouldn't have two female false percs in there).
davocean
Active member
Not likely, but hey you never know for sure what fish will do.
I had 2 occs and a maroon way back that seemed to get along, for about 6 mo.
I was all stoked at first, and posted here, and people all said check back later.
Well, they were right, maroon matured and kicked both occs butts, really bad.
I was left w/ 2 almost dead occs and one badly scarred maroon.
Had to get rid of occs.
I had 2 occs and a maroon way back that seemed to get along, for about 6 mo.
I was all stoked at first, and posted here, and people all said check back later.
Well, they were right, maroon matured and kicked both occs butts, really bad.
I was left w/ 2 almost dead occs and one badly scarred maroon.
Had to get rid of occs.
GSMguy
New member
maroon clowns and occelaris are not at all a pair that work whil all clownfish or anemonefishes are similar is one way (they host) besides the the maroon is a premnas fish and all other clowns are amorphiron SP? anyway try a pink skunk/occelaris pair that would be eisier
anything would be better than a GSM with another type of clown they usually kill even their mates eventually given enough time
anything would be better than a GSM with another type of clown they usually kill even their mates eventually given enough time
phender
Active member
FWIW: There has been a least one person on this board who has produced ocellaris X maroon babies. I'm pretty sure in his case the female was the ocellaris.
Proaquatix is a commercial breeder that was selling ocellaris x maroon hybrids that they called Coco clowns.
It is not a likely pairing, but can never say never with clownfish.
Proaquatix is a commercial breeder that was selling ocellaris x maroon hybrids that they called Coco clowns.
It is not a likely pairing, but can never say never with clownfish.
phender
Active member
There are no absolutes when you are mixing species with different personalities.
I'm not sure what you are going for here. Do you want babies? Because the maroon x ocellaris babies are not very attractive. Add the black coloring to the mix and I don't think it will be much better.
If you are just going for an unusual pair, IMHO a mixed pair of clowns is not very asthetically pleasing. Its sort of like having a clown and a Flame angel that hangs around the anemone. The mixed pair just sort of looks out of place.
I'm not sure what you are going for here. Do you want babies? Because the maroon x ocellaris babies are not very attractive. Add the black coloring to the mix and I don't think it will be much better.
If you are just going for an unusual pair, IMHO a mixed pair of clowns is not very asthetically pleasing. Its sort of like having a clown and a Flame angel that hangs around the anemone. The mixed pair just sort of looks out of place.
