Am I missing something? (mandarin dragonets)

You cannot QT mandarins because people don't have QT tanks with pods in them. They don't have to be infected to bring in an infection. Be careful.

I put mandarins up there with Copperbanded Butterflies (and clams). I will not consider anybody keeping them a success until it has been more than a year. Until that time, they can slowly starve to death and the hobbyist is all giddy that they are doing well.
 
There is a source that sells bags of 5280 copepods. How long would that last feeding a Mandarin? I have tried seeding in the past with no success, I do have 4 Wrasses in the tank though.
 
QT is a personal choice. I can't remember the last time I QT'd a fish (it's probably been 15+ years) except for a very few specific cases where there was clearly an issue. I also can't remember the last time I lost a fish to disease or parasite. I don't think I ever have, actually.

Instead of QT, I try to plan carefully when and how I add fish, and only get them from known good sources. Less work for me, less stress on the fish, I'm supporting good businesses and/or other hobbyists; everyone wins. We drill it in to newbs that they shouldn't ever put fish in a new, sterile, unestablished tank, and then we basically tell them to do exactly that in a quarantine tank, and try to pass it off as beneficial. I don't get it, honestly.

But we don't need to derail this thread. Mandarins are beautiful, I'm happy that ORA and others are breeding and hopefully we will reach a point where captive bred fish that are taking prepared food are the norm, and everyone can reclassify this species as the OP seems to be suggesting. I agree with Ron that the "expert" rating is appropriate, for the majority of Mandarins. I've cultured food in the past. It's a fun experiment, but I don't think I'd ever want to depend on it to keep a fish alive. That said, I plan on eventually getting a Mandarin for my 24g cube, as soon as I can find an established individual who's eagerly taking prepared food.
I've never told anyone new to the art to do drop a fish into a sterile tank. Having an established biological filter in your QT is hugely imortant.
 
it eats pellets? any particular brand? mine wouldn't....only thing lfs had was tigger pods...they're attracted to light so if you dumped them in they swam to the surface and went into the overflow....so had to put a nightlight in the bottom corner of the tank and dump them in at midnight so hopefully they'd wind up in the rocks or gravel or get eaten overnight....i was traveling a lot and was stupid enough to think that a mandy would be a good idea cause it would live off pods in the tank and i wouldnt have to feed it regularly...i think it ate every pod in the tank in 2 days....so 20 bucks a week for pods means over a grand to keep a 20 dollar fish alive per year...so kinda a far cry from giving a couple flakes to a damsel
 
The scooter blennies and psychedelic mandarins are the easiest to go on to pellets .
I have never tried a green Mandarin .
Ocean nutrition pellets Are wrapped in a foil package and our soft when you buy them,been using them for years.
 
The scooter blennies and psychedelic mandarins are the easiest to go on to pellets .
I have never tried a green Mandarin .
Ocean nutrition pellets Are wrapped in a foil package and our soft when you buy them,been using them for years.

Formula 1 or Formula 2?
 
vmouy9Hl.jpg

Formula 2
 
Mine is the only obligate pod eater in the 350. I still reseed every month or so to keep her fat and happy. And I keep an eye on the pod count to be sure she has enough.
 
In the last 2 or 3 weeks mine has started eating pellets. Not that it needs to, it just tried one one day. Now like my fish, he comes out when the pumps go off, eats a couple every day.

It's kinda funny, I drop a few pellets on my fungia in the front corner of my tank. He waits for the extra that don't hit the plates.

I feed New Life Spectrum marine formula 1mm sinking pellet. Everything in my tank, including corals love them.
 
h7emAvgl.jpg

He is in a 40 breeder ,no sump, eats pellets. That picture was just taken

Holy crap he's a fat little guy. lol Any special tech for getting him to eat pellets? I had one in my 75 way back that I kept for a few years till I shut down, wouldn't even think they would eat pellets.
 
http://www.melevsreef.com/node/720 , this was something I stumbled on a few years ago, I just can't remember how the guy got them on pellets. I think it had to do with quarantining the fish, filling the tank w/ live gut-loaded brine shrimp, and gradually replacing w/ frozen mysis/brine, then graduating to pellets.
 

Similar threads

Back
Top