bennerkla's 5.5 AGA Nano Reef Diary (Lots of PICS!!!)

Gotta say I have loved your thread! It inspired me to go through with going saltwater with my 5 gallon tank. Learning from you has helped a lot too! Your thread was and still is VERY informative for anyone setting up a nano, almost a HOW TO for Nanos. Keep updating and you got my vote!
 
Great post back on page 24 Ben. And congrats on the nomination!

How's that cyano issue? You said you'd been sucking it out. Have you tried increasing the flow in the tank. It can be a pretty tricky situation to increase the flow without creating a sandstorm.
 
Wow, great thread!!! I just finished reading it and I'm blown away. I needed something like this to start my own nano and now Im convinced I will. Thanks!! :)
By the way, the tank is stunning!!!! Keep updating this wonderful thread. <a href='http://www.smileycentral.com/?partner=ZSzeb008_ZN' target='_blank'><img src='http://smileys.smileycentral.com/cat/36/36_1_11.gif' alt='Thumbs Up' border=0></a>
 
Thanks a lot guys, I really appreciate it!

-I didn't say that a sump was impossible, it is just more time consuming that simply throwing on an overflow and starting a syphin because that takes up valuable space.

Sugar- The cyano is a real big pain in the neck. I wish I would've gone barebottom, because the algae is starting to grow in my xenia and zoanthids. I just added a powerhead a couple weeks ago, so I'm hoping that with time it'll die down a bit.

I'm doing a 1 gallon water change today, along with sucking that crap outta there. I wish my snails would touch it. I might try adding a few hermits to see if they start to eat it.

Also, one of my LARGEST regrets in this tank was not going with a 70 watt MH. I think that it would've looked much better, plus I could keep SPS in there. Oh well, my 76 watts of PC is still pretty powerful ;)

Cya guys,

bennerkla
 
this tank has inspired me as soon as i get enough money saved for the new xbox there will be one more tank in our house lol

BEUTIFUL tank great work
 
you could probably knock down your light schedule a little and if you can trim back some macro in your fuge. this might help with cyano..i know that stuff i a PITA
 
Turbo's are bulldozers, and although they are great in my 75, I think everything is too fragile in here for them.

I'll trim back my fuge a bit. Thanks clown.
 
I don't know if this was a coincidence for me, but I had cyano and algae problems before I tied in my 10G to my 50G system as a fuge adding around 60gph into and out of the tank via an overflow. What I did was add a magdrive mini 65 and dropped in 2 blue legs, 2 zebra legs, 2 red legs, 4 astreas, and a turbo. Algae and cyano went away very quickly within a matter of days.

Algae: The algae seemed to be trimmed down to nothing very easily. From having planted FW and dealing with plants vs algae, I was rather amazed at how quickly just a few hermits seemed to do against this form of algae. This was the hairy algae that looks like little tufts/clumps of hair, not the long stringy algae. I feel that even though hermits will crawl around on polyps and are very opportunistic eating other things other than algae, that they are #1 in algae control followed closely by turbos. But that's just my opinion and I'm very far from an expert.

Cyano. And note, I'm not saying the hermits actually ate the cyano. By observation, what I did notice was that the hermits would walk across the cyano and either ate it or they picked stuff off of it. The red legs tended to do this the most. My theory is by them getting on it and eating or stirring it up, it was kicked up a lot easier by the PH and that resulted in it going away faster. I tried to keep salinity, lighting, and water temp stable along with about 15x turnover (~65gph ph + ~80gph hob filter) and add nothing but topoff water. I didn't measure any other parameters. The only variables I did change were the animals in the tank. 3 months later no problems at all with algae or cyano. Now all I notice is big pods and my snails grazing on the spot/film algae that grows on the glass.

I don't know if it will return, but I've kinda got a feeling that with hermits, snails, a large pod population, added flow, a hardworking skimmer, and chaeto (that I added later), I am not foreseeing any more trouble with pesky algae and/or cyano. But who knows, it could happen. Just letting you know what worked for me. One thing about your setup that I've noticed--and I've been watching from almost the very first page--is that you have no hermits and you have algae problems, and I'm not sure if it's just coincidence. Good luck! I'll be watching/reading.
 
you might have said this somewhere but i probably didnt catch it. how many sand sifting snails (ie nassirus and what not) do you have in your tank? i had a CRAZY cyano algae problem in my 29 and i add more sand sifters and i was rid of the problem in 15 days
 
ben,

i think with that much light you can definately keep some digis and monti caps. i am going to try that with my 36w of pc in my 5.5
i really have learned allot from your thread. i am going to try to make a canopy like yours. i ran into the same probs with my light as you did where it didnt fit right and so on and so on. i want to add a 70w mh in my canopy but i like how things are looking so far with my pc.

i think with your algae, cyano prob a little more flow could help. i have a mj 600 in my tank along with hob filter and things are doing great. i also saw some own mentioned nassirus snails these lil buggers help allot i added about 5 of them in my tank and they took out the algae in a day where i have low flow in the tank. keep the pics coming buD!!
 
Ben, awesome job. Keep us informed. O yeah your senior year will be burned in your memory banks forever,i know mine is.


Thanks, Dave.
 
Yeah, the total on the tank was right around $700. Much more than I expected, but oh well. I might try some SPS for fun, I think they could live in there. Problem is that SPS frags are hard to come by around here without a heavy price tag, maybe Phishy has some that I could check out. Jordan do you know? Thanks for the comments guys, I'll post an updated picture here shortly. I'm still debating whether or not to remove my cleaner shrimp.
 
Any updated pics on the tank? I'm interested to see the growth rate of the frogspawn and red mushroom.

And are you coming/bringing anything to the frag swap?
 
Back
Top