Klaus Jansen said:tangblack said:I bet a deltec can, did you not read the review on the BK on reef frontiers. They had to stop as the BK was not doing that well. QUOTE]
Fairplay ??? Testing by Deltec-Dealer ?
Look the picture.... this is the same skimmer where go later to testing by Dave..![]()
![]()
![]()
running by US-Reefer
[/IMG]![]()
[/IMG]![]()
regards... Klaus
Klaus, i thought the testing was being done by a BK dealer as well as a Deltec dealer on the Deltec dealer's reef tank. That is because his system was approx 2000 gallons with a heavy bio-load.
This is the inside info I was told about the skimmer competition. First off though, I beleive the test was stopped because of the rain, we had a long we rainy season and I think there were aldo problems with a leaky sump (on a system with an auto top-off system) followed by a tank crash due to low salinity. Funny thing is, I don't think either skimmer was going to out perform the Aqua C. If you remember in the test The Deltec was to meet up head to head with the Aqua C in the first round, then all of a sudden it was replaced because a customer needed the Deltec (because of an emergency) at the last minute. The Deltec dealer had 20 skimmers on hand but the person needed that skimmer? To top it off the Aqua C was only in the competition only becase the previous owner had nothing but problems with it and replaced it with the Deltec. Turns out that if the owner wouldn't have plugged the overflow drain she would have had a rockin skimmer. The BK did have problems in preliminary tests but that is because it was said that the skimmer was taking at least a week just to get going after a cleaningand since the test was only over a 2 week period, it would not be a fair test. I do however think that seemed wierd and it was probably due to user error (BTW the BK rep was tuning it). The user was new to the skimmer at that time. I'm not bashing the BK skimmer at all because If i had the money, that is probably the skimmer that I would choose because I personnaly feel that it might just be the best ever skimmer made. My question is, does it's performance justify the price, at least 5x that of a decent performing US made skimmer? I'm not so sure. I'm pretty sure that my Aqua C will pull out at least half of what the BK does. I might just go with 2 Aqua Cs and save my money. JMHO!