Confirm my diagnosis please

N_T

New member
Ok, I've got an engineer goby with spots all over it. These spots are not as sharp and bright white as ich, more of a slimy scuzzy appearance. The fish is COVERED in it, but otherwise acting just fine, eating like a champ, and aside from its appearance, you'd never know it was sick. Today I noticed a single spot on my purple firefish. It's round, and has the same fuzzy translucent appearance. Am I right in diagnosing this as a fungus? If so, would melafix take care of this without harming my inverts (crabs, brittle star and LTA)
 
Can you post a photo? If it's covering your fish, how rapidly did it progress? Most of, what was believed to be, fungus that I've seen was somewhat isolated to one area such as the head or a fin/s. It may be something else.

Whatever the case I would look for something other than Melafix (natural based products for fish are a little like those for humans... sometimes they work sometimes not).
 
Note the fish's eye is clear, it's just a smudge on the tank in the first picture.

DSCN0985.jpg


DSCN0986.jpg
 
at first i thought it was ick as well; however, i've never seen a fish that covered in ick acting just fine, and this fish acts quite healthy. It eats voraciously, and the food I've been giving it (Ocean Nutrition #2 flakes) has garlic in it, and on top of that I've been soaking the food in additional garlic, with no change in the fish's appearance for the past week or so. I know the pictures don't really show it, but the fish has a generally hazy appearance as well. I would describe it as looking like a reptile that is shedding its skin.
 
As long as it is eating, it's likely ok. Those little buggers are always covered in raised white bumps and will have a slime about them. It looks just like mine, which I know for certain, doesn't have Crypt or Brook.
 
UPDATE:

After day 1 of the melafix, the white spot on the firefish has disappeared, leaving a slight mark on its side where the spot was. The goby looks a bit better, but not great. I dosed the melafix again, and we'll see what happens
 
Back
Top