DIY Mg additive

there should be a label on the bag. being in canada you should be able to get all these products really cheap since you have alot of snow and ice. you can get all info you need from the dead sea works website also.
 
no I haven't had to order any since I got a huge amount. I will be selling my share of magnesium though it is around 15 lb or so. I am getting out of the hobby. the source is posted in this thread somewhere
 
robthorn said:
gotcha randy thank you for all your help now my turn to return the favor to you and AL at www.harveysalt.com I talk to him and he is more than willing to ship 1 50lb bag or a hundred whatever you want. it cost me $39 and some change shipped to my house near tampa florida. he seems like a real good guy with alot of knowledge about the products he sells. he also carries the pelladow calcium chloride in 50lb bags and is more than happy to ship it to you at least in the united states.
I asked for his permission to post his name for single bag orders and he was more than happy to give it.
I ordered 1 bag today 30lb. is spoken for if anyone in my area needs any let me know and we can work something out
thanks again randy
Click to expand...

why would you pay $100 when you could have read this thread and just ordered 50lb from this link ?
as far as the real stuff that randy got if you check the manufacturers own specs the pellets are cleaner and more pure.
 
I ordered through Harvey Salt and saved a bunch compared to $100

Robthorn - didn't you have someone in the Tampa area that was carrying the stuff?

Paul
 
yes I believe if you look into this thread you will find them also if not I can look another place I am not allowed to post here on rc for it.
 
Just to be clear, RC wouldn't prevent you from posting anything except a place you have a commercial interest in, but the company itself may prefer you didn't. PM's might be a good way to deal with such issues. :)
 
someon should just order a pallet and distrubute it!

Randy - how hard would it be to keep it from getting water logged if someone had a pallet? would it keep in the bitter cold of up north (South Dakota) or would that cause problems w/ moisture

Lunchbucket
 
it is made for de icing and the bag I received was pretty thick. as long as you don't puncture it you should be good.
randy my buddy owns the other website which has no intentions of ever making money and he made me a moderator just because so since I am never going to make money off of it and I mentioned it before I was kicked off rc. so there is no commercial interest but it still matters. it is another reef forum though I guess it's still competition.
 
lunchbucket it would cost twice as much to do what you suggested since I don't think the per bag cost would be much cheaper than $20 and the shipping from place to place is not going to change much if any at all so why not just take the link other people have taken and order yourself some and save yourself a headache of worrying about it anymore
 
the link in this thread? i didn't think that was the SAME stuff. i know people thought it was but it wasn't proven it was the same grade

pm me about it will you. we'll keep conversations that could get us in trouble in PM's

Lunchbucket
 
sorry if you misunderstood my friend doesn't sell the magnesium or calcium he runs a forum so the magnesium and calcium we shouldn't get in trouble for since it doesn't benefit us or go against rc.
harvey salt is the ones that carry the magnesium and calcium. it is not exactly the same as what randy got because if I remember correctly he got it as flake and I bought pellets. it is from the same manufacturer named dead sea works out of isreal. there website states an analysis of each product and from what I could gather the pellets seem to be more pure.
you can still pm if you want I don't mind at all I just can't give the other site not even sure I can in pm if you ask for it. not sure who's watching
 
LOL pm's are PRIVATE for that reason. we should be able to talk about whatever we want

i thought that harveysalt site was what you were tlaking about. i didn't think you got a WHOLE analysis on the product and Randy couldn't comment on it for sure. or am i just confused?

Lunchbucket
 
I only got the analysis from the manufacturers website. I am sure it is not perfect but I have been using it for a long time and so have other people from this thread I assume. I do not know of anyone actually testing it outside of the manufacturer.
 
didn't Randy state something about it might not have the same quality as the stuff he ordered??? i know we haven't said a definate yes or no...but i wish we could have a full analysis from the manufacturer :(

i realize many people ahve used it for quite a while...but a lot of people used Oceanic salt before they decided they hated it or it was causing problems too. sorry i'm just being leary of anything not made for my reef.

Lunchbucket

Lunchbucket
 
As far as Calcium. I go to my local concrete plant and they give me 5 gallon buckets full of Liquid Calcium right out of a food grade 1000 gallon tank. :-)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

S
Help with Overflow Design Issue
Replies
0
Views
144
SFMAquariums
S
R
How to simplify my dosing?
Replies
1
Views
969
Vinny Kreyling
Vinny Kreyling
S
Novice Aquarist - Sump & Equipment Questions
Replies
9
Views
345
wvned
wvned
Reef Kinetics
New Salifert Magnesium Test Now Compatible with ReefBot Models!
Replies
0
Views
655
Reef Kinetics
Reef Kinetics
Formulator
8 year old tank with 2.0 PO4 and zero Nitrate
Replies
7
Views
2K
Scotty333!!!
S
Back
Top