I re-did my CD case idea. Overtime the glue came unseated, I re-glued it, and it didn't last much longer...... I re-cycled an old acrylic skimmer cup that I had left over from an old skimmer. I just re-cut the hole in the bottom and used my PVC sleeve from the original build.
I think the CD case just couldn't hold up to a weekly removal and cleaning. But then again, mine could have easily been the brittle type of plastic. It never did break, just came un-glued.