Scott,
Usually people take the bulbs out when the color or spectrum shifts. If you get an old bulb, chances are the color will not be the same. With that said, and from what I've read, some shifts are not really visible to our eye. Others are extremely visible. My XM 10K's went from a nice white to a yellow in no time (about a month). My old Ushio 10K's, appear, to be as white as when I put them in after 8 months burn. I'm sure you know this, just tossing it out. If you want to try Ushio 10K's SE, I have a couple. Very white and bright. Work great with a couple actinics to supplement.
JR