Fairy, flashers, and anthias husbandry

elegance coral

They call me EC
There doesn't seem to be a thread, at least I couldn't find one, that explains how to care for these fish. I just started stocking my tank with these fish and despite researching, I've had some problems. I was hoping we could build a thread with info that may help myself, and others, avoid mistakes.

I've searched this forum and found some really sweet pic's of fairy wrasses. Many tanks with multiple species. This lead me to purchase a blue headed wrasse and a red headed wrasse. The red head went in first. About a month later the very slightly larger blue head went in. The blue head may have killed my red head. I pulled the blue head and placed him in a different tank. My red head is missing scales and half of a pectoral fin. The blue head didn't mess with anyone else in the tank. He wouldn't leave the red head alone though. Is this normal behavior?

Just to make sure of the ID's here's some pic's.

Blue head
SN856500edited.jpg


red head
SN856504edited.jpg
 
Last edited:
I've heard rumors that some wrasses will starve to death regardless of how much we feed them. Is there any truth to this?

I also made the mistake of purchasing three bartletts. Everything I found prior to purchasing these fish seemed to indicate that they do well in trios. One of mine died in quarantine for no apparent reason. Once the other two were added to the display, one started harassing the other to the point that it can't come out of the rocks. After this happened, I found a thread explaining how this is common with this species, and you often end up with one male. I would not have purchased a trio if I would have known this in advance.
 
Anthias

Many Anthias fish species are relatively hardy, but require food often in order to thrive in the home aquarium. Generally, they require a variety of plankton feedings because they have a high metabolism and small mouths. Mysis, fish roe, Nutramar ova, and cyclopeeze tend to work well with some taking black worms as well. Due to the complex social structure of Anthias, it is advisable to keep one specimen per tank unless you have a relatively large tank (e.g. greater than about 125 gallons. These fish are serial hermaphrodites with dominant females able to change into males. In large groups there will be one or more males and multiple females. Clearly these fish cannot be intermixed with fish that will eat them. Some species of anthias can be mixed while other highly peaceful ones cannot be mixed with aggressive ones.

Q. Can I keep anthias in my reef tank?
A. Yes. Anthias are planktivores which are well suited for a reef display. They will not bother corals or other invertebrates. The smallest shrimp may be in trouble with some of the larger species, but even that is unlikely.

Q. Do anthias need to be kept in groups?
A. Generally speaking, for many of the hardy, more commonly available species, no. Often the more aggressive, outgoing species are in fact better kept as single specimens, especially in the confines of a smaller tank. Most anthias have a complex social structure, which can lead to fighting in a home aquarium. More timid species do better in groups; providing them a sense of security which a single fish would lack.

Q. How many anthias can I keep in my tank?
A. This will depend on the species, tank setup/equipment, and husbandry/maintenance. While many species are small, relative to other commonly kept marine fish, their feeding requirements can put a significant strain on a system. Often, one will run out of biocapacity due to increase in the bioload of the tank before they run out of physical space for the fish. They are also very active, constantly swimming.

Q. Do I need to QT anthias?
A. Yes. Acclimation to captivity is the first reason. Newly imported anthias are often starved, and unaccustomed to eating prepared foods. They will often only accept the smallest, frozen meaty foods, and then, only in tiny portions, very frequently. They must be adapted to eating larger foods, eating more food per feeding, and competing for food with other fish. This is all much easier to do in a separate QT system, without the presence/intimidation from other established, more aggressive feeders. Of course, the second reason to QT is to observe the fish for disease. Bacterial infections, as well as worms/flukes are not uncommon.

Q. Can I keep multiple species of anthias in the same tank?
A. Generally, yes, depending on the species and the size of the tank. Anthias will pay much more attention to conspecifics, than to other species around them. Even males of multiple species will often live together without problem, especially if they have females to occupy their time.

Q. How do I tell females from males?
A. Depending on the species, some can be very easy to tell apart (ie orange female lyretails vs red/purple males) while others have only subtle differences, like dispar anthias.

Q. Why are my anthias fighting so much with each other?
A. Anthias all start as females. The most dominant fish will turn into a male. If that male dies, the next most dominant female will turn into a male. Because of this dynamic, each fish is always trying to keep its place in line, or advance to the next higher position in the group. In an ideal situation, amongst a group of females, one will be clearly dominant, and turn male; and the other females will have established places in the hierarchy as well. Complications arise when females that have already begun to turn male (not easily visible to us, if at all) are placed in a tank with a full male, or even another changing female. Adding new fish to already established fish can also cause issues. It is best to add a group one species all at once. If adding more fish to an already established group, it is best to only add small females, so there is no question to their sex, or their place in the group (bottom of the totem pole). New fish must be in excellent health. Anthias will detect and attack sick individuals, regardless of size or sex.

Q. Can anthias be kept with other fish?
A. Anthias get along with most other fish. More aggressive anthias species can bother very timid fish, and of course small species can be swallowed by larger predatory fish. But otherwise, they play well with others.

Q. Do anthias need to be fed five or more times a day?
A. Anthias do best when fed small amounts of food often. Many of the hardy, more commonly available species can be acclimated to each larger amounts, less frequently, and do just fine. Again, QT is invaluable for this process. It may take weeks to months for newly imported specimens to regain their proper body mass, so frequent feeding may be critical at first.

Q. What should I feed my anthias?
A. Any and all manner of small meaty foods can be fed. Finely minced frozen shrimp, squid, scallop, clam, mysis, plankton are just a small sampling of easily obtained foods. More finicky species may require live foods at first, or even throughout their time in captivity. High quality dry foods may also eventually be accepted.

Q. My anthias won't eat, now what?
A. Try every food you can get your hands on. Also, fast movement of the food can often trigger a feeding response. Food blown out of a powerhead is an excellent way to achieve this. Live foods may need to be tried as well. Try mysis, capelin fish roe, cyclopeeze, nutramar ova

Q. Do anthias jump?
A. Like all fast moving, active fish, anthias have the capability of jumping out of the tank. Often this can happen when individuals get excited about the prospect of being fed. This can also happen during quick chasing incidents from other fish. Otherwise, generally speaking, anthias don't bolt for the surface haphazardly.

Q. Why did I have more than one anthias turn into a male?
A. There is no easy answer. Perhaps the “femalesâ€Â were already in the process of changing, at least internally. Perhaps whatever stimuli keeping the females from changing were not present with only one male in the system. Sometimes multiple males will change, and still be able to live in the same tank. Other times, one or more fish will have to be removed, or risk death.
 
Fairy Wrasses

All members are relatively small and sexually dimorphic. they usually occur in large groups in the wild and are planktivores. The coloration of juveniles and females is often very similar which makes it difficult to determine what species you have in some cases. Most species (with some exceptions that are highly aggressive) are ideally suited to the home aquarium. They are not compatible with basslets or dottybacks. Best if fed multiple times per day. Those whose body coloration is blue based lose the most coloration absent a female.

Q.: Are fairy and flasher wrasses different?
A.: Yes. Flasher wrasses are a member of the genus Paracheilinus and there are 13 currently identified. Fairy wrasses are a member of the genus Cirrhilabrus. There are about 50 currently identified with more coming along frequently.

Q.: Are the personalities of all fairy wrasses the same?
A.: No, some are docile, some are very aggressive. In general, the females are more aggressive than the males. The more aggressive ones such as C. scottorum may eventually become intolerant of other fairy and flasher wrasses. More often though, you can mix and match fairy and flasher wrasses with no problem. Best way to introduce new ones is with an acrylic acclimation chamber.

Q.: Do you need sand for fairy and flasher wrasses?
A.: No. They create a mucous cocoon when the sleep.

Q.: Do you need to have a female along with the male?
A.: No, but the "blue group" (those whose body tends to be blue based) tends to lose more coloration absent a female than does the "red group".

Q.: Can I keep two male fairy wrasses of the same species together?
A.: Generally no. They will fight. Also, in general two male fairy wrasses of similar size, coloration, and body shape can be problematical. The same is not true for flasher wrasses.

Q.: What kind of acclimation is required for fairy wrasses?
A.: Temperature acclimate, SG acclimate, and socially acclimate by floating new arrivals in a breeder cup to dispel aggression.

Q.: Will fairy and flasher wrasses jump?
A.: Yes. Not a question of IF but WHEN.

Q.: Will egg crate keep them in?
A.: No, you need quarter inch holes or a sealed tank.

Q.: What are the rarest fairy wrasses?
A.: In the USA, C. earlei, C. johnsoni, and C. lanceolatus "types" are rare

Q.: Do all males lose coloration?
A.: No. If you have females, the male coloration should remain constant and if you are lucky you will observe breeding behavior

Q.: What is a terminal male/supermale?
A.: A terminal male cannot revert to being a female. These are also called supermales.

By the way, questions about fairy wrasses are expedited by using their real name e.g. C. solorensis
 
Keep in mind that male flasher wrasses can conflict. My mccoskeri ripped the lower jaw off of my lineopunctatus within the first week of them being introduced, both being approx. equal in size.

Aggression between the two eventually did dissipate to manageable (though still cruel, IMO) levels. Whether this was was because they came to some sort of understanding, were well fed, or because another larger more aggressive fish was added (Potter's Angelfish)... I just don't know.

Just saying, I won't be doing it again until I've got a much larger display to disperse aggression and allow for territoriality.


As to Anthias, I keep 4 resplendents quite well in a 75 gallon display. Introduced as 3 females and one already male. There is a distinctive size difference between all 4 fish with the male being the largest. He tends to keep his women in the center region of the tank where they've claimed an area of dense branch rock with many small nooks and caves as their own. About 80% of the time he is off swimming with the clownfish pair. The rest of the time he is in super-male mode, he flattens his dorsal fin to his back and colors up big time... the change in coloration is absolutely stunning! While doing this he chases all 3 females rather relentlessly for a few seconds to a couple of minutes, he never bites them or really even touches them, but they know to move out of the way. I would worry if I only had 1 female that she'd catch to much of the aggression. The 3 seem to weather it quite well and all eat voraciously and have become very colorful since first introduction.
 
Last edited:
To introduce more than one male flasher wrasse, try using a social acclimation chamber. It really helps diffuse the aggression prior to physicality. I believe bradleyj has an excellent picture of his.
 
There's tons of info in this thread............it's huge & has split many times, but there is invaluable info on which wrasses get along & which are bullies, ect. I believe bronco7777was the first to introduce everyone to using the specimen containers & start the explosion of popularity of these fish.

http://reefcentral.com/forums/showthread.php?t=761763

This thread is also pretty good..........

http://reefcentral.com/forums/showthread.php?t=828181


Another good way to get aquainted with the species you want to buy is know the scientific name & do a search. If you hang around this forum for a few months you'll also get a good idea of which wrasses will get along, are hardy/difficult, ect.

Nice job on those summeries of care Steve!
 
Thanks for all the great responses.:thumbsup:

I'll be going to buy a social acclimation chamber, SAC today. I have a long fin fairy wrasse (Cirrhilabrus rubriventralis) in quarantine that will be going into the display today. Hopefully the SAC works. How long should I leave the new guy in the SAC? I have a female blue headed wrasse (Cirrhilabrus cyanopleura), and a blue flasher (Paracheilinus lineopunctatus) in the display now. Unfortunately, the red headed wrasse (Cirrhilabrus solorensis) never came out of the rocks this morning.:sad2: I'm sure it died from the wounds it received from the male blue headed wrasse (Cirrhilabrus cyanopleura).
 
Thanks for all the great responses.:thumbsup:

How long should I leave the new guy in the SAC?

There is no fixed time period. If there is going to be major heartburn from a current inhabitant, you will know immediately. Be sure the new wrasse is eating in the SAC and that aggression from current inhabitants has subsided. For me the time period has varied from 3 hours to 2 days (two lights off times).
 
Back
Top