Judging by the number of coral sales on the mars forum, I'd say it's time for a swap. People are so much more willing to give away stuff during swaps, which is great for the hobby. Even if we don't get that great of a selection with two swaps a year, I think it's better for bringing in new people. How many new people do we get with each swap? And just how many people from our club went to the BAR swap? I think 2 swaps a year is still good, since Bar has gone to one a year. 3 a year between the two, sounds good to me. Of course I don't have to plan this stuff, so ultimately it just depends on if the officers can do it.