not meaning to hijack, but I have been having similar problems. I have always had a rule, kill something once, it could have been a fluke, kill somthing twice and you need to stop and figure out what you are doing wrong before trying again. Well, I bought a colony of zoas that never opened and about a week or so ago I found the rock that use to have the zoas on it was clean. So I got a second cononly and it too never opened and today I awoke to find that rock clean, so I started looking at my other frags and noticed an emerald crap picking at the zoas.
Now, when I first started this quest for a zoa filled tank, I thought they were sick due to water, which now tests out perfect, I have good flow from a Tunze Wavebox and good lighting, so now I am woundering if I have a muncher.
I have not seen any sundial snails and know I dont have any nudibranches, and as for the other 2, I am not sure if I have them or not due to the size of the critters.
My question is, do emeralds eat live zoas or only pick at dead/dieing ones?
Anything else I can look for that could be eating these guys or making them sick?