Garibaldi damsel

pIankton

New member
I thought these fish were endangered?

I saw 2 of them for sale today at a LFS and it struck me strange. They were both still small - maybe 3" or 4" in length with their blue spots still...
 
Oh - OK, that actually made me think about them being a temperate species as well. Plus the fact of seeing Catalina Gobies in the tank next to them had me thinking otherwise.
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=15312068#post15312068 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by rendogg
Garibaldis and Catalinas are temperate water fish.

Their suitability for the reef tank will vary on where they were collected. I have friends here in NC with catalinas in the reef collected from local waters (ie, very hot in the summer) that do very, very well.
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=15320282#post15320282 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by redfishsc
Their suitability for the reef tank will vary on where they were collected. I have friends here in NC with catalinas in the reef collected from local waters (ie, very hot in the summer) that do very, very well.

Catalina gobies are endemic to the Eastern Pacific with nothing looking like it in the Atlantic for the most part.
What you are seeing most likely is not that unless someone has released them and they took ;)

pic_Fis-24760.jpg


http://fishbase.org/Summary/SpeciesSummary.php?id=3885

Lythrypnus dalli (Gilbert, 1890)
Bluebanded goby


Distribution
Eastern Pacific: Morro Bay in central California, USA to Guadalupe Island off northern central Baja California, Mexico.

Lydal_u1.jpg
 
I suggest those of you who had posts removed check your attitude.
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=15320494#post15320494 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by GreshamH
Catalina gobies are endemic to the Eastern Pacific with nothing looking like it in the Atlantic for the most part.
What you are seeing most likely is not that unless someone has released them and they took ;)


The ones I saw looked just like what you have in the pic (and catalinas I've seen in person).


It's possible that they are a transplant like you mentioned, or a similar specie. The Audubon Society Field Guide to North American Fishes don't mention them being in the east coast either, so they obviously aren't native there.
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=15320282#post15320282 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by redfishsc
Their suitability for the reef tank will vary on where they were collected. I have friends here in NC with catalinas in the reef collected from local waters (ie, very hot in the summer) that do very, very well.

They come from the Eastern Pacific.... it's pretty cold there. There are relatives that live in the Atlantic and Caribbean, although kind of similar, they are not Catalinas. The map may be deceiving, in all the literature I could find Catalinas are only found around California to the Baja Peninsula. But seeing as this was a post about Garibaldis this thread should not be derailed anymore. Garibaldis have the same distribution as the Catalinas.
 
Last edited:
The local aquarium in Newport Kentucky keep there water at 65 degrees for there garibaldi. I thought that was really cold but they looked happy. They also seemed very shy unlike most damsels.
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=15336412#post15336412 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by stumpovrtyme
The local aquarium in Newport Kentucky keep there water at 65 degrees for there garibaldi. I thought that was really cold but they looked happy. They also seemed very shy unlike most damsels.

Having scuba dived off of catalina and the channel islands I can tell you that garibaldi are not shy, but in fact very territorial. They will chase and nip at you if you get close to their "domain". Not sure how they would do in a reef tank but I would guess they would be pretty aggressive.
 
Thats what I thought but I couldn't hardly even get a look at them. I also thought they were red but there actually orange thought that was pretty cool to learn.
 
Garibaldi will grow to a foot long regardless of the tank. They are also the meanest fish you will ever encounter. You'll find them all over the place in San Diego and we had at least 30+ of them when I was an intern for the birch aquarium. Their a fish simply not appropriate for the home aquarium.

The Juvis are born about 50% blue, as they grow up they kind of become a spotted blue and as they are adults they are bright orange. From what I learned about them, the blue is kind of a marker so adults won't kill them. They are the most territorial fish in the ocean. They will not take crap from a human, shark, sea lion, nothing.
 
^^ pretty much spot on w/ my exp w/ them as well.
They are the only fish that actually swim up to the tip of my spear and stare at it, like, "I dare ya!"LOL
 
Back
Top