Yeah once a formal structure comes into play , human nature gets political and those issues tend to dwarf the reef issues and take some of the fun out of it all.
The folks we had leading the effort here were stellar though and genuinely interested in the good of the hobby and the animals and folks in it. We were lucky to have them step up and try it and had some nice events and dialogue.
Not all are like that. A formal club can get a life of it's own that isn't always in sync with what it's members want out of it.Some of them tend to silence members and take odd and confrontational positions reflective of the idiosyncrasies of some club officers and not the other hobbyists in the geographic area ,they claim to represent.
I like the open informal way with many voices . It seems to suit an evolving dynamic hobby. It encourages indepedent action. Anyone with an event idea only has to be willing to guage interest on this forum and then do the work of coordinating it.Anyone with a position on a reefkeeping technique only needs to state it and be prepared to defend it without acrimony.