Learning/rebuilding from my epic fail

Mutt since your growth and colouration is excellent, with those high values of no3 and po4, did you ever consider that those high values are actually favourable for your corals? Looking yours and Joe NY reefs, remembering what has been written on sceptical reefkeeping about po4, reeding Mr Bailing advising po4 concentration of 0.1ppm as optimum values and mainly looking my reef with no3 2.5ppm, po4 hovering between 0.2-0.4 due to Lars syndrome :) and no ill effect, I wonder if nutrients levels are critical only at the beginning of a reef ,for controlling algae outbrakes, but in an established reef, higher values are actually favourable for all corals?
 
Happy New Year to you, your household, and your reef.
Your reef is continuing a level of excellency that few attain.
I agree with Greg's thinking posted above. Once a reef matures and hits it's healthy, happy place; it seems to tolerate a wide range of conditions. The nutrient level that once made the reef turn brown now brings about the most pure saturated colors.
Thanks again for all the pics and knowledge that you passed on in the last year.
 
Still waiting in anticipation (The Full Tank Widescreen Reef Porn)
Video pending! It requires the extra step of downloading to the computer and then uploading to utube, so it is taking longer.. I'll get there..
hey Matt!

good to hear and your latest pics are just incredible.
for sure it would be better to get those parameters a bit down but as we can see by your example low po4 and no3 isn´t all that counts!!
i think tabatalk works just fine for me ;)

my tank... hmmm... :lolspin:
after i had a lot of problems with keep the parameters in check due to a lot in my office and all the pre christmas things going on and now i decided to switch over to full triton method. a lot of my friends are running that system and have not to much maintenance and great success!!

will post some pictures soon! ;)

ps.: maybe i´ll visit Montreal in the upcoming fall 2018 ;)

Cheers
Thanks!
Flo, let me know when you come to Montreal! Don't come soon, though, it's currently one of the coldest places on earth...
No question triton is working for a lot of people. Will you use an algea fuge?
I guess I just don't know how to navigate tapatalk very well.. anyways, it works for posting pics..
Mutt since your growth and colouration is excellent, with those high values of no3 and po4, did you ever consider that those high values are actually favourable for your corals? Looking yours and Joe NY reefs, remembering what has been written on sceptical reefkeeping about po4, reeding Mr Bailing advising po4 concentration of 0.1ppm as optimum values and mainly looking my reef with no3 2.5ppm, po4 hovering between 0.2-0.4 due to Lars syndrome :) and no ill effect, I wonder if nutrients levels are critical only at the beginning of a reef ,for controlling algae outbrakes, but in an established reef, higher values are actually favourable for all corals?

Happy New Year to you, your household, and your reef.
Your reef is continuing a level of excellency that few attain.
I agree with Greg's thinking posted above. Once a reef matures and hits it's healthy, happy place; it seems to tolerate a wide range of conditions. The nutrient level that once made the reef turn brown now brings about the most pure saturated colors.
Thanks again for all the pics and knowledge that you passed on in the last year.

Greg, Kevin thanks you and happy new year to as well!
The whole nutrient issue is very perplexing.
I do believe my nutrient are too high- even if they aren't really affecting the tank negatively.. although I do have some rust brown spots in the sand which I assume is dinos and this brown stringy funk growing in the frag tank. Will add flow in frag tank.. so even though most of the Corals are doing great with high nutrients, I thinks they probably be growing and looking different/better in lower levels..
Nuisance algae is generally at a low though.
I still have a handful of Corals that are not doing well or not growing. Every time I have a period of lower nutrient, more of those dormant Corals seem to wake up. Once awake, however, they continue to grow even when nutrients climb again..
Your point about established reefs being more tolorent of nutrient swings seems like a very good one. There must be something to that.. stable bacterial levels and general microfauna populations must allow the Corals to adapt better to highs and lows..
I still feel that for all around reef happiness, my levels are slightly too high..
Having said that, the real key here is that I am not trying to do anything about it in any big hurry..
I'm going to give it a few more weeks for sure and see if things creep down slowly- I think they will..
My plan, thereafter is to start a low dose of a carbon source.. maybe vinegar or nopox.. not so much as a real nutrient reducer (although, it will have a reducing effect) but just as an added element to the nutrient cycle in the tank..
 
Matt your tank is looking amazing! Truly inspirational



What is that colony middle left in this picture? Looks like a tenuis with purple tips, pink/green body and deep red polyps.



Thank you!
That is one of my pink matrix colonies..
This is an older pic of a different colony from a different Canadian vendor:
87d2ac6f32d8f5d053ed52e33eb7e05c.jpg

Couple more close ups from a few months ago..
This pic is of the specific coral you asked about above.
0e15bb8069a3d0a679dca1439929d2c0.jpg

One more.. it is quite a beautiful coral and is growing well.. it'll need some fragging very soon..
793a6d4eb3d2016d31ee95de2fc8de5a.jpg



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Wow Matt, your colours are impressive, wish I could get there.
I have also noticed that these deep colourations are very possible in a higher nitrate and phosphate readings. Great progress- and thanks for sharing!!
 
Flo, let me know when you come to Montreal! Don't come soon, though, it's currently one of the coldest places on earth...
No question triton is working for a lot of people. Will you use an algea fuge?
I guess I just don't know how to navigate tapatalk very well.. anyways, it works for posting pics..

i will tell you for sure! will be fall 2018
i will implement a fuge in my existing sump, just had to order a new piece of glass and glue it in. should be done mid January

as long as you keep those pictures coming!! :bounce1::bounce2:

cheers
 
Thank you!
That is one of my pink matrix colonies..
This is an older pic of a different colony from a different Canadian vendor:

Couple more close ups from a few months ago..
This pic is of the specific coral you asked about above.

One more.. it is quite a beautiful coral and is growing well.. it'll need some fragging very soon..



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I really like the colours on this variant of tenuis!
 
Matt as always everything is looking great!

With your levels that high, what do you think contributes to you not having much bad algae? Everytime mine get high, I get this really annoying green turf algae. I wish I could keep my levels maybe a little below yours but high as my corals always look the best then but at the same time green turf algae takes over.

Also, how are your levels that high? Are you feeding a ton everyday?
 
Happy New Year Matt! Your tank keeps looking better and better. I'm not sure I would change anything about your nutrient levels as your tank is looking like a TOTM. I always enjoy stopping in and checking out your beautiful corals and wonderful photography. :beer:
 
Happy New Year Matt,

Do you think you'll have the video done some time before 2019 :strange:
Just kidding.

Your Coral Colors Photos continue to amaze me.
 
Wow Matt! Your corals are looking outstanding! Beautiful pieces you got in your tank! Happy new year buddy!
 
Happy New Year, Matt !!!

Last year you have been very diligent in posting those very nice pictures. Please keep doing it this coming new year. We all enjoy them very much.
 
Hey Matt.

every triton test I have gotten my strontium is always low, around 2-3 so I was thinking about dosing it. I saw you dosed some back in May. I wanted to see if you are still dosing and if so, have you noticed a difference in anything or what is your experience?
 
Hey Matt.

every triton test I have gotten my strontium is always low, around 2-3 so I was thinking about dosing it. I saw you dosed some back in May. I wanted to see if you are still dosing and if so, have you noticed a difference in anything or what is your experience?

Hey Cody, the fact that you have constant measurable sr. means your tank is always getting some..
I tried dosing for only a short while but didn't find it really helped anything..
I abandoned using it pretty quick..
 
Back
Top