LED fixture lighting help (replacing old T5 HO)

jeffo65

Member
Hi,

I need to replace an old T5HO light fixture (AquaticLife series 4200) and have noticed that most fixtures are now LED. I have a 46 gallon bow front tank. Have have soft corals (mushrooms, toadstools, etc) which are doing fine under the current T5 HO (96 watt) fixture. I am confused on the LED fixtures as they don’t have a wattage. What led fixture would be similar / recommended as a replacement for my current fixture?

Thank you
 
I don’t understand what you mean by LED fixtures don’t have wattage. I’ve been researching them lately and all I’ve looked at have wattage listed. What lights have you looked at?

What corals do you keep and are you more budget concerned or do you want top of the line?

@Reefing102 is my go to source for LED info.
 
Lighting is all going to depend on budget. If I recall a 46 bowfront is 36 inches wide. So my recommendations are based on that.

As mentioned, most LED systems list a wattage, however wattage in LED does not equate to wattage in T5 and Metal halide. With LED the common reference point people use is par which requires the purchase or rental of a par meter.

Many of the LED reef lights will be sufficient for what you want. You’ll probably be looking at at least two fixtures for that size tank.

At the top price end: Two of any of these: Radion XR15 or AI Hydra 32 should provide enough coverage.

Mid Range Price: Reefi Uno 2.0 (should just need one but may have coverage issues at the edges unless you hang it a bit higher).

Low End: one: Viparspectra, two SmatFarm, one NiCrew 150, two Noopsyche or similar would work.

In the end it boils down to price, features, warranty and related support (or lack thereof), and ultimately coverage. In the low price point I didn’t specify too many models (some models will have better coverage, features, etc than others).

For example, the Viparspectra is 2 channel control and does not have an app last I knew. SmatFarm is 6 channel control but no app and as I have one of the G5 models, quite frankly the spectrum leaves a bit to be desired to really get that color “pop,” but it grows coral and anemones just fine. NiCrew, I personally wouldn’t buy another NiCrew product unless significant advancements have been made but that’s just my personal experience with the lack of control in the one light I’ve purchased (there have been several good reviews of the latest NiCrew reef light). Reefi Uno has a great reputation but the app and UI can be a bit dated looking.

With that said, almost all of the above combinations have a higher maximum wattage when ran at 100%. However given the par requirements (or lack thereof) of the various softies, you likely will not be running any of the fixtures near 100%.

I hope this helps!
 
Hi,

I need to replace an old T5HO light fixture (AquaticLife series 4200) and have noticed that most fixtures are now LED. I have a 46 gallon bow front tank. Have have soft corals (mushrooms, toadstools, etc) which are doing fine under the current T5 HO (96 watt) fixture. I am confused on the LED fixtures as they don’t have a wattage. What led fixture would be similar / recommended as a replacement for my current fixture?

Thank you
You need to narrow your needs/wants.
I mean one could suggest a 35" Reef breeders Meridian led for $1000. That would be like a "form factor" replacement with 225 watts max power.
But maybe it's too pricy (wasting watts) or the " color" you want to run it at means you lose a ton of watts.
Or too complicated. Or they need to be ceiling mounted.
See there are a LOT of details one needs to consider.

Yes " par" ( ppfd) is the most reasonable way to judge a light but from past ( and others pasts from fw to horticulture) you should have little issue if you replace your 96w of t5's with 96 watts of LEDs
But dimming should be an included function.


Keep in mind your 360 degree light spread from the tubes create a very different light field than most LEDs.
So the look is different.
LEDs increase their efficiency by being a more focused light source. 120 to 60 degrees and changes the overall look to more dynamic/3d.
 
Back
Top