<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=8815290#post8815290 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by kpk
Paul just a quick question, why is a 400w more than needed for a 30' tall tank? Over 24" or so 250's don't have that much punch down low. Ask Kevin his 250s sucked with 10k bulbs on the bottom of his 105g 29" tall tank with about 6" of sand. 30" is quite a ways to penetrate.
What sort of corals are you planning on keeping? And can you, perhaps, choose to keep corals higher up (in the middle or top of the tank) that will require more light? And then can you choose to keep corals lower that will require less light? I believe that utilizing these methods, we can probably get away with burning less watts over our tanks.
And, for the record, I am using a 250W Metal Halide over my 30 inch tall 47g tank in Dallas. My sand bed is about 2-3 inches. And I am doing exactly as above - SPS corals (one ORA blue Tort Acros and some Montis) up in the mid-high tank region. And less demanding stuff (an LPS and Zoantids) down lower.
I may be wrong. But I really do believe that we put too much light over tanks when we start using 400W MH bulbs. IMHO, overkill.
Take this on to clams - the ones that are more light loving (T. maxima and T. crocea) are rock clams and can be place higher up, in the rockwork. And the lower light ones also happen to be the sand clams (T. derasa & T. squamosa) and can be placed down low.
Just my opinion, of course. I am just always a fan of finding ways to be more energy efficient with our tanks, and more practical.
Whatever the case, I am sure it will work out. And if you do the light rail, then I am anxious to see pics, etc...
