So I came late to this party and took a long time to read the whole thread. I have built many LED lights from the time that this thread started until now. I to have my own opinion of what spectrum works and what doesn't. I tend to lean toward slower growth and premium coral colors (after all aren't we all trying to enjoy the colors of the things we are growing?).
I've done 1W, 3W, 5W, 10W, 20W, 50W, 100W, Dream Chip, Lumia 5.1 and Lumia 5.2 builds. All of them have had pluses and minuses. The interesting part is that I finally found a setup that is truly working better than I ever could have expected and the only mentions of it in this thread have been negative with no good reason to back it up.
So here is my addition to this thread. I have been running 6 18" fixtures each containing 2 Lumia 5.2 chips on each. These are running over 4 different sized tanks 120g 72x18x24, 65g, 40g breeder, 28g nano. None of them are running at 100% output but they all are setup so that during peak output of the day all channels are running at the same output. They may ramp up and down at different rates but they all meet at there specified output for the daily peak.
I have noticed two very interesting things with this setup and configuration. First, the colors in the corals both during daylight and during the florescent periods are easily twice as vivid as before. Second, growth has been on par or higher then I used to get with T5's. Those two things to me are amazing.
In all of the other configurations and builds that I have done with LED's it has been very hard to get good colorization of Orange, red, and yellow corals. The colors are either pale (dim) or they are over bright (bleaching). With these new chips these colors are bright, deep, and rich! They have turn ok corals into incredible corals. I am attributing this huge difference to a combination of the lower K whites (adding a bit more red and amber to the spectrum)as well as the new turquoise channel that they added. Turning the turquoise channel on by itself makes any red, orange, or yellow just pop (not glow like RB's do) but just make them impossible it ignore in the tank.
Growth on softies, LPS, and SPS has been the best I have had with LEDs. In fact my acans grow so fast I have to keep them on their own islands so they don't grow onto my rock work and take over. Some of them (I wish it was all of them)are producing 1 new head per week. I couldn't ask for more.
I designed a board that in corporates an Arduino and 6 LDD drivers onto it and mounts to the lights. This one board allows for simple connections (2 wires for power and an ethernet cable) for all controls. So the leads from the chips never leave the fixture (very neat). The Arduino on the board can be programmed to either be a 0-10v analog to PWM converter (Like the steve's board), or a stand alone (think Typhoon) light controller just by loading different software on the board.
I'll post some pics of this setup so everyone can see what I'm talking about.
What I'm really trying to say in this long winded post is, As much as you might think that a specific multichip configuration may not seam like it will work, That may not be the case. If you are at all considering doing your own multichip build I personally would tell you to look into the Lumia 5.2 (no I am not affiliated with the group buy site). They are working great.... no better than great for me and I am extremely happy with them. I put my tried and true Radion G3 Pro and one of my Lumia 5.2 lights over the same tank 1 week ago. I'm taking pictures of the entire process and will have a thread to show the results. I've got my money on the Lumia. The change to Cree, Exotic and Osram seems to be paying off in that chip.
All I can say is wow! Krazie :jester: