I learned my skimmer really well with the straight in, I can make it do what I want.
I tried putting the up and over back on and it was horrible. I had to jack my air/water way up to get it to skim like it was with the straight in.
The reason I went straight in was because I called the pump manufactures about the up and over. Their exact words were "These pumps are great and pushing water, not so great at pulling it."
I researched the subject more and found that people are using pipe 2X's the size for the up and over, then reducing it right before the pump.
I tried this but got a surging effect.