Ahh...that makes sense. Thanks Steve.
Wow, you are fast! By the way, I do advocate for CP for parasites other than crypto.
My journey using Chloroquine Phosphate begins...
- Thread starter b0bab0ey
- Start date
Wow, you are fast! By the way, I do advocate for CP for parasites other than crypto.
You'll come around eventually.
I know you advocate CP for Velvet. But what about Brook & Uronema?
You'll come around eventually.
I know you advocate CP for Velvet. But what about Brook & Uronema?
There is no literature basis for that while for velvet, there is. Based on my understanding of the life cycle for B&U, it should work very well, if of course, you have a good source for getting the pure drug. My problem with using it for cryptocaryon is with no long term studies on its effects on fish, and with a fool proof non-chemical solution to eliminate it from fish, it is difficult to prefer it to tank transfer. The other issue with cryptocaryon irritans is that the back end of the life cycle is no where near as deterministic as it is with V,B,&U. As such the four week treatment should work most of the time, but not all the time. There are so many variables involved as to when the vulnerable stage of the life cycle is released. Copper treatment is similarly disadvantaged, perhaps even more so, since we know copper is bad for fish longer term.
But, I personally always encourage leading edge exploration of new treatments (or old treatments done differently) in our hobby. What we all need to do is carefully note the environment we are using it in in order to control determining the general applicability to additional situations. In peer reviewed literature, this is done, or if not done, peer reviews don't go very well. We all need to try to adopt a similar level of rigor.
Deinonych
New member
Awesome! I'm gonna call these people later to verify it's 99% pure CP.
hvacman250
New member
FWIW, I have been treating my 55 QT tank with 80mg/gallon of 99.9% pure CP for the past 4 weeks. Two clowns, one spot foxface, regal tang, 2 pajama cardinals, and a yellow coris wrasse.
Total lights out except feeding, 10 gallon water change once per week (adding 80 mg/gal back to water change). Ammonia badge has always registered zero, but I do have some rock and seeded filter media in the tank. Today ends my 4 weeks and all fish look great.
Total lights out except feeding, 10 gallon water change once per week (adding 80 mg/gal back to water change). Ammonia badge has always registered zero, but I do have some rock and seeded filter media in the tank. Today ends my 4 weeks and all fish look great.
hecticreefer
In Memoriam
Hey Steve, I'm trying to read more from the sticky at the top of the forum:
http://www.reefcentral.com/forums/showthread.php?t=2159738
Are there references somewhere that I'm missing? Like for example you wrote "(Yambot et al, 1993)" but then there is no link or reference at the end of the post. Is this an original article from somewhere else?
Where detailed information is presented, the name of the author is provided and the date it was published. Since the data was a summarization, I did not provide the total paper since space would have been prohibitive and the sum and substance of the paper would not have been interesting. However, if you wish, use Google Scholar and you can get the paper in its entirety. Or, alternatively, you can purchase the book Captive Marine Fish by Stephen Spotte.
Recently added 40mg / g dosage of CP for QT - 2 days later, I'm noticing that there's an ICH outbreak on certain fish in QT. I would like to raise it to 60mg / g in total;
Do I need to remove all CP first and redose it at 60mg / g OR can I just add another 20 mg/g worth to compensate for the difference?
Do I need to remove all CP first and redose it at 60mg / g OR can I just add another 20 mg/g worth to compensate for the difference?
coral49
New member
Has anyone been successfully with treating/QT wrasses? I am a firm believer in CP. Good success with QT. Over the last year QT flame back, bicolor and annularis angle. yellow and mimic tang railway goby.
No luck with wrasses, lost a 6 line and a cleaner.
I'd like to get some but won't use copper again.
No luck with wrasses, lost a 6 line and a cleaner.
I'd like to get some but won't use copper again.
jnc914
Active member
I have had success using CP with fairy and flasher wrasse, but not with leopards. Have you considered Cupramine instead of straight copper? Cupramine seems to be gentle on more delicate fish. I have had success with it in the past. The only issue is that it can be difficult to get a good copper level reading.
yes, i've had luck with cupramine and CP. you saying you had those losses with cupramine or what type of copper treatment or CP?
if cupramine, are you slowing bringing solution up to therapeutic levels? what levels are maintaining and over what period of time are you raising levels? you are not mixing with other treatments or water conditioners, correct? i haven't had any losses using cupramine even with more sensitive species when bringing cupramine up to therapeutic levels over the course of a 7-10 days.
coral49
New member
I've kept it very simple for QT practices, CP 4 weeks (40mg/g - single dose), water change then treat Prazi 2 weeks, (2 cycles). Off to DT. I've either been very lucky or it works. No out breaks. Fish come out eating well and ready to go.
Ich has haunted me on previous tanks, lost fish or had outbreaks using both copper/cupramine. Just not interested in using that again.
Great news on flasher and fairy.
Ich has haunted me on previous tanks, lost fish or had outbreaks using both copper/cupramine. Just not interested in using that again.
Great news on flasher and fairy.
Deinonych
New member
So, I just received a shipment from NFP (not CP - some other meds including Paracide-X). The return address read "Fishman Chemical," so I suspect they are supplying the same grade of CP. Caveat emptor.
That sucks. I emailed NFP about their CP, but never received a response. I had planned on ordering some CP from them and Nitrofuracin Green Powder. But if they can't even bother to reply to an email, F 'em.
Interesting. I sent them an email asking about specific dosing weights for some of the meds I ordered, and received a response within minutes. Maybe they know their CP isn't pure.
So, at this point, where is the most reliable source of pure CP?
