*Need Help (Pics)*

<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=14417054#post14417054 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by Tswifty
Yep... it's hands down the best skimmer for the money.

sjm817 did some side by side testing, and the MSX outperformed his ATI.

Do you have a link?

Also, I'm fed up with my current system of sump and changing water. I'm going all out and making a new custom sump. I would like lots of input as to how make the compartments.

I'm planning on roughly 5 ft x 2 ft x 2 ft

It will sit to the left, perpendicular, and below the tank I have. I have a good visual idea in my head but will draw up some sketches.

I'm also going to do some pvc plumbing right to a pump so when it comes time for water changes i just pump it down the drain. Tired of buckets...
 
http://www.marinesolutionsinc.com/c.../index.html?osCsid=jm1me3n9viebve46it3e6gk496

I feel hear you on the buckets... On the 220 I was putting together I had a SW mix station planned as well as a series of valves and PVC for draining the sump... so basically I would be able to perform water changes without picking up a single bucket.

The reason there is a price jump from the 200 to the 250, is that the 250 utilizes 2 Sicce pumps, while the 200 only uses 1. Also Marine Solutions makes a custom extended neck for the 250 that is supposed to really boost the performance. I'm not sure how much it costs though.
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=14418250#post14418250 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by Tswifty
http://www.marinesolutionsinc.com/c.../index.html?osCsid=jm1me3n9viebve46it3e6gk496

I feel hear you on the buckets... On the 220 I was putting together I had a SW mix station planned as well as a series of valves and PVC for draining the sump... so basically I would be able to perform water changes without picking up a single bucket.

The reason there is a price jump from the 200 to the 250, is that the 250 utilizes 2 Sicce pumps, while the 200 only uses 1. Also Marine Solutions makes a custom extended neck for the 250 that is supposed to really boost the performance. I'm not sure how much it costs though.

Interesting. I found what you are talking about. It is $99
http://www.marinesolutionsinc.com/c...on-Cup-for-MSX250-or-MSX300/product_info.html

I think what I'll do first is make myself a new sump, then really monitor the skimmer, maybe there is something at fault on my part (probably).

I have an auto drain on it so I closed it off for now (today) and am measuring the results. Will post in a few days what it collects.


Any ideas for the sump are appreciated.
 
chatyak, you do have some diatoms and what looks like dinoflagellates and some bryopsis, for the diatoms put some crabs to work, for the bryopsis get your mag up to the 1500 ppm and it will wither and lastly for your dinos, their is no sure fix for it but you could try feeding less, using a denitrifier to lower nitrates,
phosban for phosphates, reduce your light cycle or shutoff your lights for 3 days (all this tips will help you with your other algaes as well).

Oh on the dinos, dont do water changes, those mostly fuel new growth and if you try to remove them by hand, dont let them float away as they will grow somewhere else....

Believe me been there done that

Sana
 
I didn't see your params posted anywhere... I'm interested in what your Nitrates and Phosphate levels are? If your hair algae is dying off for one reason or another, Nitrates and Phosphates are going to be released. While most would be hopefully taken up by a reactor or chaeto (if you're growing), some will undoubtedly be consumed by other forms of algae.

LifeReef skimmers are great. Sounds like you might need to adjust yours to accumulate junk appropriately. What is your feeding cycle like, and what are you feeding?
 
Thank you sana. I am not familiar with dinos (except the extinct ones), what do these look like and how do they act?

I am currently planning a new sump to help streamline maintancce on the tank and it needs the following sections.

Bubble tower, skimmer section, return, refuge, separate tumbling chaeto compartment with a spray bar, and room for a gfo/carbon reactor.

Estimated dimensions are 60" x 20" x 20".

However I also need to store a freshwater supply above the sump because I like to use my gravity fed auto top off... so we need some sort of stand over the sump...
 
Last edited:
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=14419737#post14419737 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by Tylt33
I didn't see your params posted anywhere... I'm interested in what your Nitrates and Phosphate levels are? If your hair algae is dying off for one reason or another, Nitrates and Phosphates are going to be released. While most would be hopefully taken up by a reactor or chaeto (if you're growing), some will undoubtedly be consumed by other forms of algae.

LifeReef skimmers are great. Sounds like you might need to adjust yours to accumulate junk appropriately. What is your feeding cycle like, and what are you feeding?

Don't have a phosphate test kit ( i hear they don't work well since all the phosphates are being used by the algae anyways).

I have to clean out my gfo/carbon reactor because i dosed an alkalinity supplement near it and it's all caked over with precipitate, but yes I just got one of those and the LifeReef of course.

I changed the skim to a wetter one, with the water line being about .5" of an inch below the neck line. We will see how much it fills up and whether this is bad or good from your opinions.
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=14419737#post14419737 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by Tylt33
What is your feeding cycle like, and what are you feeding?

I feed flakes about twice a day to the clowns and some leftover bits the tang gets. I feed nori to the tang about 2x a week and leave it in there until he gobbles it all up.

Mysis shrimp, frozen brineshrimp and bloodworms here and there randomly to mix it up.
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=14419784#post14419784 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by chatyak
Don't have a phosphate test kit ( i hear they don't work well since all the phosphates are being used by the algae anyways).

I have to clean out my gfo/carbon reactor because i dosed an alkalinity supplement near it and it's all caked over with precipitate, but yes I just got one of those and the LifeReef of course.

I changed the skim to a wetter one, with the water line being about .5" of an inch below the neck line. We will see how much it fills up and whether this is bad or good from your opinions.

My LifeReef skimmer took some tweaking before it really started pulling out the nasties. Stick with it.

I use a Salifert PO4 test kit, and I found it to be very accurate and helpful. I made the rookie mistake of adding chaeto to a dark part of my refugium, where it died, and released all of its goodies back into the water. I tested PO4 before and after water changes, and it changed appropriately. Gave me a good idea of how far I needed to go :)
 
Interesting point about the chaeto releasing the stuff back into the water... a couple of months ago I thought nothing of it when mine died (wasn't turning etc...)..
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=14419921#post14419921 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by chatyak
Interesting point about the chaeto releasing the stuff back into the water... a couple of months ago I thought nothing of it when mine died (wasn't turning etc...).. couple of fueled a bit of junk.. hmm

Mine was in a small tank (~30g), and I brought it over from the sump of my 120g. When it died it caused an algae bloom like I had never seen before in my tank, due to all of the nitrates and phosphates being again available for algae intake. Something to think about.
 
Update to the sump... compartments I'd like to have are...

Intake bubble tower, skimmer section, LR section, refugium, tumbling chaeto section, return, and a spot to place my gfo/carbon reactor where I can see if it's tumbling ok inside the canisters.
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=14419951#post14419951 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by Tylt33
Mine was in a small tank (~30g), and I brought it over from the sump of my 120g. When it died it caused an algae bloom like I had never seen before in my tank, due to all of the nitrates and phosphates being again available for algae intake. Something to think about.

Yea very good points. When it dies it turns white right?
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=14420035#post14420035 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by chatyak
Yea very good points. When it dies it turns white right?

Or just disappears into nothingness.
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=14420061#post14420061 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by Tylt33
Or just disappears into nothingness.

Yea sounds about right.. well while the tank is being "fixed" I'm going to think of a super sump design. Trying to get some ideas in my head as to how it will all work out.
 
What about this design? Looking top down.

100_3035.jpg
 
dinos=dinoflagellates, is an algae that is very stubborn to erradicate, the faster you start the better your chances are of getting rid of it....good luck

sana
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=14419288#post14419288 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by sanababit
chatyak, you do have some diatoms and what looks like dinoflagellates and some bryopsis, for the diatoms put some crabs to work, for the bryopsis get your mag up to the 1500 ppm and it will wither and lastly for your dinos, their is no sure fix for it but you could try feeding less, using a denitrifier to lower nitrates,
phosban for phosphates, reduce your light cycle or shutoff your lights for 3 days (all this tips will help you with your other algaes as well).

Oh on the dinos, dont do water changes, those mostly fuel new growth and if you try to remove them by hand, dont let them float away as they will grow somewhere else....

Believe me been there done that

Sana

You said to raise Magnesium to 1500ppm? What does this do exactly?
 
Back
Top