new derasa from diversden

Just a guess, but I think it may have been the torch coral living above.. I'm certainly no expert on clams, but I know that Torch's are pretty aggressive and have sweeper tentacles that could definitely reach your clam..

but either way, I suggest buying from your LFS. .. that way you can see exactly what you're buying and can watch the clam.

Good luck on your next one!
 
You should be able to do a maxima without issue. My only concern would be the calcium levels. In a 24g tank, a clam can absorb quite a bit of calcium on a regular basis.
 
I have a maxima clam in my 29 gallon Biocube. I've had it now for several months now and it's doing great, showing new growth. My lighting is a 150 watt MH. Like Genetics says they do suck up a lot of Ca. As a matter of fact, I dose Alk, Ca, and Mag. daily. I also have several sps corals, so I try to stay on top of Ca levels.
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=13568510#post13568510 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by dragonette
I read that derasas are supposed to be THE easiest or at least one of the easiest... so Im a little leery about getting another if I already killed the 'bulletproof' one.

What do you guys think? maxima on the rock? 8" from surface of a 150w halide?

A gigas is the easyest i think, and I also have bad luck with Derasa clams. I do best with squamosa's
 
We just received a new shipment of clams... They are now on our website if you want a heads up and we will also be adding more on Sunday evening as well... Lots of teardrop maximas, and squamosa's...

Hope this helps,
Chad D. Bryant
 
I had a derasa that spent several weeks touching its mantle against a large hammer coral in my old 36 gallon bow before I finally got my 120 setup. The clam had nowhere else to go at the time, but it never reacted negatively to the hammer. (I think it is the same family as a torch... correct me if I'm wrong)

For whatever its worth, I kept my derasa under 2 150 watt MH for about 16 months, during which it doubled in size. It was on the sandbed 20+ inches from the lights. You should be able to keep a derasa in your current setup. It looks like you maintain it very well. As others said, just get your Ca up where it should be and I think you could be pretty confident to give it another shot. Sorry for your loss.
 
thanks guys for all the comments and recommendations :)

Im going to wait until I get the solana to try another clam, so hopefully I will have better luck next time.

The torch coral was not within reach of the clam, just fyi... but yes, the torch could have/would have stung the crap out of the clam if it could, they are lethal to anything they touch:( but I am in love with torches so its hard to give them up.

Ill keep you guys updated. My husband gets his bonus in about a month so Ill be getting that solana pretty soon!
Im going to set it up next to my current tank, let it cycle etc, and transfer everything over. The only thing in the tank I am going to change is the substrate.. going to switch to black!

Keep in touch!
Jess:eek1:
 
hi Dragonette

I'm sorry about your loss. As others pointed out, though, your tank does look beautiful and it's clear that you take good care of it.

I have a Derasa, 4 Maximas, and a squamosa. In my opinion, your problem w' the Derasa stemmed from one of these 3 reasons...

1) Maybe too much light/heat. It's a small tank, and the heat & light from your MH might have stressed out that deeper-water clam.

2) Chemical warfare: With a tiny tank, there's lots of chemicals getting emitted from your other coral. Perhaps something (like that torch coral) disagreed w' your clam, stung it, and rendered it lifeless. This seems a bit less likey- given the relative peaceful nature of most of your coral...

3) Night-time predators. Like someone else pointed out, you might have some worms in your sandbed, pyramid snails, or some other predatory nocturnal invertebrate. Clams have sturdy exteriors, but are vulnerable at their foot. If any hungry critter is residing in your sandbed, it might have attacked the Derasa.

I hope this helps. If I were you, I'd just wait on a clam, and focus on something else cool (like an Aussie Acan, donut coral, or another type of LPS). By introducing another one you're risking not only that clam, but all the other coral in your tank. As you quickly learned, a decaying clam creates a foul stench and can pollute your tank (esp. a little tank like yours) in such a harmful way.

IMO, the upside doesn't outweigh the high risk.

Best of luck w' your tank, and, again, sorry for your loss.

-Flamehawk
 
Back
Top