You might want to double check what Pete actually posted through this thread. It sounds like you are refering to someone else's post(s) here ^
I was just responding to the reply that stated.
"Its not about the money, Its about the way that DSA will treat you if you buy one of their tanks."
"Maybe if they see this thread they will jump through hoops. "
"Maybe they will read this thread and find out it cost them a few sales."
"Even Saltwater aquariums said they are not good with customers"
As I stated , I don't think he's in the wrong. He purchased the tank with a stand and should get, as stated in the 7 year warranty, a repair or a replacement with no extra charges, including no freight charges.
But when dealing with wholesale companies you have to abide by their policies for that to happen. If you buy a tank from Petsmart and it fails, if you call the manufacturer they will tell you to return it to Petsmart. Because that is the terms they set forth with Pet Smart. Which is why Saltwater Aquariums really stated " They lack in areas where their hands are tied."
The warranty agreement that DSA had with The Fish Store is to return the tank to the Fish Place for either a repair or a replacement. In this case since it appears to be a small leak in the silicone, They could repair the tank in house, without having to send it out ,two ways freight to Dallas. Or have to replace the entire tank if unnecessary . And even though The Fish Place is not taking orders from DSA now, for reasons that we do not know. Maybe they aren't selling enough tanks to meet DSA's requirements, or maybe there are other reasons. Either way, If The Fish place is still operating as a business, they are still liable to meet the terms of sales at the time of purchase. Obviously they are not doing that. So as Salt water aquariums stated, DSA's hands are tied. Unless they return the tank to The Fish Place, or another distributor.
To me it sounds like he didn't want to go that route because as he stated it is 200 mile away. And he wants DSA to just sent him a new tank at no cost with freight paid. Without allowing the fish place to inspect the tank and make the repairs.
If this tank was brand new DSA might have handled things differently. I don't know. But because this tank has been up and running for a year, with no problems, Im sure they want one of their local distributors to inspect the tank and stand to make sure, as stated in the warranty, it hasn't been altered or damaged in anyway that would violate the warranty.
My point was , not that he shouldn't get his tank repaired or replaced free of charge, but that he would probably have to go through the proper channels in order to do so. As idiotic as that may sound.