I found a real odd duck last night, I'll see if I can sneak some pictures tonight, but someone might have an idea just from my description and its behavior.
It's an anemone that appears to be nocturnal. During the day, it is curled up completely within a hole through a piece of LR, entirely shielded from light.
Last night I saw it sticking pretty far out of the hole. Its body was only slightly slimmer than its mouth disk, which was just about 1.5" across. A perfectly pie-shaped slice of its mouth and mouth disk was white, roughly 1/5th of the surface. The rest of the anemone was brown. It had fairly stubby tentacles with rounded tips, each about 1.5". After about 10 seconds in the flashlight, it started to withdraw.
I'm stumped. It's shaped and colored like a photosynthetic anemone, though it doesn't look quite like a mojano or aiptasia. The fact that it hides completely from the light, and that I haven't noticed it despite having this piece of LR in the tank for nearly a month (and I've done lots of flashlight hunting) suggests that it isn't photosynthetic. The short tentacles look like they wouldn't be all that good for prey capture.
Anyone have any ideas?