Red/Blue Carpets and long term success?

Re: Re: Red/Blue Carpets and long term success?

Re: Re: Red/Blue Carpets and long term success?

<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=12381655#post12381655 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by Gary Majchrzak
species is a more important factor for success than color.
Only experienced anemone keepers with the proper set up should attempt S. gigantea

S. haddoni is a much better choice for those with less experience.
Gary,

What is a proper setup for Gigantea? The most I know is good light and water quality and left/right water flow. Man, those blues are beautiful! Do Giganteas also come in red? I have never seen a red Gigantea.

And what signs to you look for for healt, besides they look good and are sticky? I have had a green Haddoni for a couple years now, and it has always done well.
 
sorry for the delayed reply, Cathy

sorry for the delayed reply, Cathy

IME the two glaring areas that gigantea and haddoni husbandry differ are lighting and feeding.
gigantea will require much more attention and TLC than a haddoni in a similar situation.
*haddoni will try to avoid heavy water motion while gigantea requires it to survive
*haddoni can (possibly) do just fine under lower lighting while gigantea demands intense lighting (and regular feedings)
*haddoni will eat all sizes of food while gigantea seems to do better with smaller sized foods (only)
*gigantea might start looking sickly if water temps start dipping into the mid 70's while haddoni seems to handle such "cooler" temps just fine

many anemone keepers having experience with these two species report that haddoni will move if uncomfortable ("unhappy") while gigantea rarely moves on it's own and will likely die in the spot you place it before it moves to a better perch

haddoni is the fish eater- gigantea isn't nearly as fond of sushi as haddoni.

I hope this helps.

FWIW gigantea are more delicate than haddoni. This probably contributes to their lower tolerance for shipping handling and acclimation.
 

Similar threads

Back
Top